Britain Celebrates Free Speech by Arresting 60,000 People

Britain Celebrates Free Speech by Arresting 60,000 People

Satirical Illustration

Britain Celebrates Free Speech by Arresting 60,000 People to Make Sure Nobody Abuses It

Home of Magna Carta Introduces Exciting New Footnote: “Terms and Conditions May Apply”

Britain, the ancient birthplace of parliamentary liberty, common law and men standing on wooden boxes shouting opinions at strangers, has reportedly celebrated its continuing commitment to free expression by arresting at least 62,199 people for communications offences over five years.

The figure comes from research by civil-liberties campaign group Big Brother Watch, and was highlighted by the Mail on Sunday and subsequently in the BBC’s newspaper review. The campaign group says around 18,000 of those arrested were charged and 12,292 convicted.

This is Britain, however, so nobody should jump to conclusions without completing Form FS-17, “Application to Reach a Premature Conclusion in a Public Setting.”

Form FS-17 is available online, although clicking the wrong box may constitute communication.

Britain remains absolutely committed to freedom of speech. You may say whatever you like. You simply have to find out afterward whether you were allowed to say it.

Freedom of Expression Remains Available by Appointment

Government officials reassured the nation Sunday that free speech had not been abolished, nationalised or accidentally left on the 08:47 to Birmingham.

“It remains one of our most cherished liberties,” explained a hypothetical spokesman from the newly consolidated Department for Speech, Silence, Facial Expressions and Potentially Sarcastic Punctuation.

“Citizens remain entirely free to express themselves between the hours of 10:30 and 10:45 on alternate Wednesdays, excluding bank holidays, provided their speech has been countersigned by a solicitor and does not cause psychological inconvenience to a Labradoodle.”

Britain’s arrangement is not censorship, officials stressed. Censorship is something foreigners do. Britain has guidance. Guidance is censorship wearing a cardigan.

The Government Would Like to Clarify That Jokes Remain Legal, Probably

There is an important factual complication beneath the comedy. The 62,199 arrests should not be described as 62,199 people arrested merely for expressing political opinions. Communications offences encompass conduct ranging from potentially unlawful offensive communications to menacing messages, harassment-related behaviour and threats. The Crown Prosecution Service specifically distinguishes credible threats and targeted abuse from speech that is merely offensive or shocking.

Excellent. That makes everybody feel better. Britons merely need to determine where their stupid joke ends and criminal law begins before pressing “send.”

Fortunately, the CPS provides guidance. Unfortunately, reading British prosecutorial guidance requires the concentration previously associated with decoding the Rosetta Stone.

The current CPS guidance says Article 10 protects freedom of expression and stresses that prosecutors should only proceed when interference with that freedom is necessary and proportionate. It specifically says cases should generally involve something more than offensive, shocking or disturbing speech, satirical or rude comment, unpopular opinion, banter or humour.

Satire is protected. Wonderful news for this newspaper. We will nevertheless be keeping the engine running.

Britain Discovers the Constitutional Right to Be Arrested and Released

The arrest-to-conviction numbers provide the most interesting statistic. Big Brother Watch reports at least 62,199 arrests, around 18,000 charges, and 12,292 convictions.

In other words, roughly one person was ultimately convicted for every five arrested.

The British authorities may consider this reassuring. Critics may reasonably ask a different question: what happened to everybody else?

Apparently they received the traditional British complimentary gift basket containing fingerprint ink, several hours of inconvenience and the comforting knowledge that the system ultimately worked out they probably should not have been convicted.

Imagine applying this method elsewhere. A restaurant brings meals to 62 customers. Eighteen ordered them. Twelve actually eat. Management announces an enormously successful dinner service.

Free Speech Now Varies According to Local Weather Conditions

A Postcode Lottery for Liberty

Perhaps the strangest finding is geographic. According to Big Brother Watch, Cumbria Constabulary recorded 25.7 arrests per 10,000 people over five years, while neighbouring Northumbria recorded 1.9.

That is a remarkable disparity between adjoining policing areas operating under the same national legal framework. Apparently a sentence can cross the county line and undergo a complete legal personality change.

In Northumbria: “That was a tasteless comment.” In Cumbria: “Turn around, please.”

Britain has therefore created the world’s first postcode-sensitive theory of free expression. Estate agents will soon advertise houses accordingly: “Charming three-bedroom semi. Good schools. South-facing garden. Excellent broadband. Low communications-arrest density.” House prices could finally become comprehensible.

Magna Carta Receives Mandatory Software Update

Magna Carta was sealed in 1215 and helped establish the principle that government power itself was constrained by law. This was considered quite revolutionary.

Eight centuries later, British civilization has refined the principle: “No free man shall be seized or imprisoned except through the lawful judgment of his peers, due process of law and whatever happened in the family WhatsApp group at 11:47 p.m.”

Section 127 of the Communications Act 2003 makes it an offence to send through a public electronic communications network certain messages that are grossly offensive, indecent, obscene or menacing. The courts and CPS have subsequently established a high threshold intended to protect freedom of expression.

Britain has therefore achieved an extraordinary legal sandwich. Top slice: free expression is fundamental. Bottom slice: grossly offensive communications may be criminal. Middle filling: several million lawyers arguing about lunch.

Police Urged to Investigate Traditional Crimes Occasionally

Free-speech campaigners have inevitably asked whether police resources might occasionally be diverted toward activities traditionally associated with policing. Burglary. Shoplifting. Car theft. Assault. Finding whoever keeps putting those tiny milk cartons in hotel rooms.

The Free Speech Union’s Toby Young has argued that excessive online-speech arrests risk producing a chilling effect and diverting police attention from crime on the streets. Big Brother Watch similarly argues that vague communications laws and inconsistent enforcement need review.

Police understandably face a difficult job. A burglar may flee. A tweet just sits there. It has a timestamp. Frankly, tweets are considerably more cooperative suspects.

“You posted this at 9:42?” “Yes.” “Excellent. If only the catalytic-converter people kept metadata.”

Britain Introduces the Speech MOT

A government efficiency task force is therefore expected to unveil the Annual Speech MOT, under which every adult will bring their opinions to an approved testing centre.

An inspector will examine sarcasm emissions. Irony alignment. Offensiveness tread depth. Dangerously loose political opinions.

Anyone failing will receive fourteen days to correct the problem. The Ministry recommends replacing worn opinions only with government-approved equivalents.

For example: “Politicians are idiots.” may be upgraded to: “Certain public-sector stakeholders present opportunities for competence enhancement.”

And: “This law is ridiculous.” becomes: “I welcome the government’s ambitious journey toward discovering whether this works.”

That is not censorship. That is British customer service.

Americans Attempt to Understand the System, Give Up

Across the Atlantic, Americans observing Britain’s speech laws expressed confusion because Americans solve constitutional questions by shouting “First Amendment!” until someone produces a Supreme Court opinion.

Britain has no single codified constitutional equivalent of the American First Amendment. Instead it possesses statutes, common-law principles, Human Rights Act protections, Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, prosecutorial tests and approximately seventeen miles of explanatory footnotes.

The British approach certainly has nuance. A little too much nuance. Ask an American whether his speech is protected and he says: “Hell yes.” Ask a British lawyer and he says: “Well, what precisely did you say?”

This difference explains both countries completely.

The Right to Offend Matters Most When Somebody Is Offended

The serious point hiding underneath the clown nose is that freedom of expression does not matter much when everybody agrees. Nobody needs constitutional protection to announce that puppies are pleasant.

Liberty becomes relevant when somebody says something foolish, unfashionable, offensive, satirical, politically obnoxious or simply irritating.

The CPS itself acknowledges this principle. Its guidance stresses that freedom encompasses speech capable of offending, shocking and disturbing, and that restrictions must satisfy necessity and proportionality.

Which leads to the uncomfortable question raised by 62,199 arrests: even if many arrests concerned conduct that deserved police attention, is Britain setting the intervention threshold in the right place?

That question is not anti-police. It is pro-liberty. A free society should be extremely reluctant to make an arrest the opening move in an argument. Otherwise every argument acquires handcuffs.

Government Announces Freedom Remains Completely Safe Somewhere

For now, British officials insist the great national inheritance remains secure. Magna Carta remains at the British Library. Speakers’ Corner remains in Hyde Park. Parliament continues debating. Newspapers continue publishing. Citizens continue insulting politicians.

The machinery of liberty remains visibly intact. It just seems somebody has fitted parking sensors to it.

Every few seconds: BEEP. Opinion detected. BEEP BEEP. Unpopular adjective approaching. BEEEEEEEEEEP. Somebody in Cumbria has opened Facebook.

Britain has not yet abolished free speech. Far more characteristically, it has surrounded free speech with regulations, guidelines, legal tests, regional variations, compliance officers and downloadable explanatory PDFs until ordinary citizens begin wondering whether saying anything is worth the administrative risk.

The nation that once told kings they were subject to law now appears increasingly tempted to tell Kevin from Wolverhampton that his meme requires context.

Which brings us to the official definition of modern British liberty: you are completely free to speak. Please remain where you are while we determine what you meant.

15 Humorous Observations From Britain’s Thriving Free-Speech Industry

  1. Britain still guarantees freedom of speech. Unfortunately, freedom of speech now appears to have the same opening hours as the passport office.
  2. More than 62,000 communications-offence arrests in five years suggests Britain has finally found a crime wave it knows how to investigate: typing.
  3. The country that gave civilization Magna Carta has updated the document for modern times with one additional clause: “By continuing to speak, you agree to our terms and conditions.”
  4. British citizens remain free to express unpopular opinions, provided they first determine whether Constable Nigel from Cumbria considers the adjective sufficiently popular.
  5. Campaigners say Cumbria recorded 25.7 communications arrests per 10,000 people over five years while neighbouring Northumbria recorded just 1.9, suggesting free speech may now depend on your postcode and possibly your choice of motorway exit.
  6. At least 62,199 arrests produced only around 18,000 charges, which means tens of thousands apparently participated in Britain’s newest civic tradition: being investigated before everyone decides there wasn’t enough there.
  7. The Crown Prosecution Service says merely offensive, shocking, rude, satirical or unpopular speech may be protected, which is reassuring information to receive shortly after somebody confiscates your telephone.
  8. Britain has achieved the bureaucratic miracle of simultaneously insisting free speech is robustly protected while creating enough paperwork around speech to deforest Wales.
  9. “Grossly offensive” has no single statutory definition, which seems wonderfully efficient because Britain has 70 million people available to disagree about it.
  10. British policing has apparently evolved from “What seems to be the problem, sir?” to “What exactly did you mean by the laughing emoji?”
  11. There was once a British policeman whose chief responsibility was catching burglars. His grandson now requires screenshots.
  12. Free speech in Britain increasingly resembles complimentary hotel Wi-Fi: technically included, occasionally unavailable and governed by 47 pages nobody reads.
  13. Parliament could simplify matters enormously by issuing every citizen an approved list of opinions, updated quarterly according to prevailing weather.
  14. Americans have the First Amendment. Britain has several statutes, prosecutorial guidance, proportionality tests, Article 10 jurisprudence and apparently a bloke from compliance.
  15. Britain has not abolished freedom of speech. That would be authoritarian. Britain has simply placed it behind a customer-service counter and asked everyone to take a number.

Disclaimer

This is satire. Threats, harassment and genuinely criminal communications are not the same thing as controversial opinions, jokes or political speech, and the 62,199-arrest figure encompasses a broader category than people simply being arrested for expressing views.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *