British Economic Dynamism

British Economic Dynamism

Downing Street Less Ruled Too Short

Downing Street Asks Business What Government Can Do for Them; ‘Less’ Ruled Too Short for Agenda

Burnham promises to rediscover British economic dynamism as archaeologists begin digging beneath Whitehall for last known traces of it

LONDON — Britain’s leading business executives have been invited to Downing Street to explain what government can do to encourage investment, entrepreneurship and economic growth, setting up what may become the shortest meeting in British administrative history.

“Less,” replied business.

Archaeologists Search For Economic Dynamism
Archaeologists Search For Economic Dynamism

Officials reportedly stared at the agenda.

There were three hours remaining.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham is promoting what he calls a new partnership with business, promising to encourage entrepreneurship, investment and companies that want to grow.

The concept represents an intriguing change in British economic management because the government has traditionally approached successful businesses much as a Labrador approaches an unattended Sunday roast.

Admiration first.

Then interest.

Then absolutely everything disappears.

Whitehall Discovers the Private Sector

The meeting follows Burnham’s promise of a “culture shift” in how Britain treats business, including making companies easier to start and expand.

This immediately raised a disturbing question.

What was the old culture?

Business owners across Britain may answer by gesturing toward the filing cabinet.

For decades, the British entrepreneur has participated in a curious national obstacle course.

First, come up with an idea. Second, raise capital. Third, hire employees. Fourth, find customers. Fifth, negotiate planning rules, employment rules, energy costs, taxes, permits and paperwork. Sixth, become successful. Seventh, appear on television while a politician explains that people like you need to contribute more.

The eighth stage consists entirely of accountants.

Burnham now wants Britain to rediscover the dynamism necessary to create successful companies.

This may require archaeologists.

Teams equipped with carbon-dating equipment have reportedly been dispatched beneath Whitehall after rumours that several fragments of entrepreneurial enthusiasm survived a departmental reorganisation in 1997.

One object initially believed to be a fossilised venture capitalist was later identified as a Treasury official waiting for approval to purchase a printer.

Treasury Buys Doughnut Franchise

The fundamental contradiction in British economic policy is spectacularly simple.

Government wants businesses to succeed. Government also wants successful businesses to provide more money.

This produces an economic philosophy comparable to Weight Watchers purchasing a doughnut franchise and then expressing disappointment at the weigh-in.

The Treasury wants investment. Investment creates profits. Profits create tax receipts. Government therefore encourages investment while occasionally behaving surprised that investors care what happens to the profits.

A businessman investing £10 million does not generally begin the morning saying, “My principal objective is creating a larger taxable event for somebody in Westminster.”

He may be patriotic. He may love Britain. He may own three Union Jack waistcoats and sing Jerusalem while brushing his teeth.

But at some point he performs arithmetic.

Arithmetic remains one of the Treasury’s most dangerous political opponents because numbers stubbornly refuse to attend press conferences.

Government Offers Partnership

Burnham’s government wants to act as a “partner for growth.”

This has caused particular nervousness.

A conventional business partner contributes something to the enterprise and shares both risk and reward.

Suppose Sarah opens a manufacturing company in Leeds. She puts up her savings. She borrows against her house. She works sixty-hour weeks. She hires twelve employees. She develops a product. She finds export customers. She spends four years terrified that one bad quarter will result in her explaining insolvency to a bank manager named Clive.

Finally, Sarah makes £500,000.

At this point the government emerges from behind a hedge shouting: “PARTNER!”

Sarah may reasonably ask where her partner was during the previous four years.

Was the Treasury unable to locate Leeds?

If partnership genuinely means partnership, government should participate when Sarah loses money. She reports a £200,000 loss. The Treasury sends its portion.

“Terribly sorry about the year, Sarah. As your partner, enclosed please find our share of the catastrophe.”

Businesses should not organise their cash flow around receiving that envelope.

Britain Launches Twenty-Minute Capitalism Trial

There is another strategy. It is radical. It costs almost nothing. It requires no new department. No regional coordinator. No stakeholder consultation. No £18 million branding exercise featuring a multicoloured arrow pointing northeast.

For twenty minutes, government leaves productive people alone.

That is it.

Britain could select Tuesday between 10:40 and 11:00 a.m. During this experimental period, nobody announces a new business levy. Nobody changes the rules. Nobody creates a regulator. Nobody launches a consultation. Nobody announces a five-year industrial strategy containing the word “ecosystem” 214 times.

Entrepreneurs simply entrepreneur. Builders build. Engineers engineer. Shopkeepers shopkeep. Investors invest.

Software developers continue doing whatever software developers do while staring angrily at three monitors.

At 11:00, economists measure the results. If gross domestic product has not collapsed and Birmingham remains approximately where it was, Britain extends the experiment to thirty minutes.

Eventually this may become known as the National Productive People Non-Interference Pilot Scheme. Unfortunately, giving it that name would require a programme director, twelve policy advisers and a £4.7 million communications budget.

So perhaps just call it Tuesday.

Business Asked What It Needs

The Downing Street summit offers business executives a rare opportunity to tell government precisely what they require.

Predictability. Competitive taxes. Affordable energy. Functional infrastructure. Planning systems that do not treat the construction of a warehouse as though someone has proposed rebuilding Stonehenge indoors. Rules that remain sufficiently stable for companies to make long-term decisions.

And perhaps fewer people in Westminster announcing that the private sector needs government to teach it how to create wealth.

Britain’s businesses already know how to create wealth.

That is why the Treasury keeps looking for them.

One Leeds factory owner, asked what government could do for business, kept his answer shorter than the agenda allowed: “Turn up when we lose money too. Then we’ll talk partnership.”

The complaint has numbers behind it. The CBI and Energy UK have been arguing for months that high electricity prices are suppressing business investment, and the CBI has separately told Chancellor Healey that roughly £345 billion in business costs, including energy prices around 45 percent above the G7 median, are weighing on investment ahead of his October Budget.

This suggests the business problem may not be a shortage of inspirational speeches.

A factory does not become more competitive because the Business Secretary describes it as part of Britain’s “growth ecosystem.”

It becomes more competitive when the electricity bill stops resembling a ransom note.

Government Searches for Missing Dynamism

Economic dynamism itself has now reportedly been placed on the endangered-species list.

Last seen sometime between the invention of the steam engine and the creation of the online planning portal, dynamism is described by experts as a shy creature that flourishes around capital, competition, incentives and people prepared to risk their own money.

It tends to flee when approached by eleven regulators carrying clipboards.

The government hopes to reintroduce it into its natural habitat. Whitehall scientists caution that the animal must first complete an environmental impact assessment.

Researchers at the entirely satirical Prat.UK Institute for Things People Already Knew conducted a nationwide study asking entrepreneurs which government programme would most encourage them to expand.

Seven percent requested grants. Nine percent requested training. Fourteen percent requested better infrastructure.

Seventy percent simply whispered: “Please stop inventing things.”

The survey has a margin of error of plus or minus whoever answers the Treasury consultation.

The Success Tax Problem

There is also Britain’s peculiar emotional relationship with successful people.

Government wants risk-takers. But successful risk-takers possess money. Money immediately makes government curious.

Imagine Britain trying to encourage Olympic sprinters using the same logic.

“Run as fast as possible,” says the coach. The athlete wins. “Excellent. We’ll be taking one shoe.”

Next race. “Wonderful. Another victory. Hand over the other shoe.”

Six months later, Parliament commissions a report entitled Why Britain No Longer Produces World-Class Sprinters. The report recommends a National Running Strategy.

Cost: £3.2 billion.

Whitehall Discovers Cause and Effect

The libertarian argument here does not require government to disappear into the North Sea.

A functioning market economy needs law, property rights, infrastructure, courts, public order and predictable rules.

The comedy begins when government moves from referee to player, coach, stadium owner, hot-dog concessionaire and man insisting everybody complete a diversity questionnaire before kickoff.

Governments establish the environment. Businesses conduct the business. That distinction is useful because civil servants are generally not risking their pensions when a new factory fails.

Entrepreneurs are.

That difference produces information. A person risking his house pays unusually close attention to whether customers actually want the product. A committee risking somebody else’s taxes has greater flexibility.

Burnham’s Cheapest Growth Strategy

Burnham may therefore have identified something valuable with his proposed “culture shift.”

Change the culture. Reward enterprise. Encourage investment. Make starting companies easier. Let successful firms become larger.

But Britain should resist the irresistible temptation to turn “supporting entrepreneurship” into another enormous apparatus for administering entrepreneurship.

The ultimate libertarian growth strategy remains alarmingly inexpensive: try leaving productive people alone for twenty minutes and see what happens.

If nothing happens, government can return at 11:01. If something happens, try an hour. Then perhaps a morning.

Before long, Britain might find factories being constructed, companies expanding and investors putting money into the country without anyone commissioning a PowerPoint presentation titled Unlocking Cross-Sectoral Synergies for Sustainable Entrepreneurial Delivery.

This could become dangerous.

Businesses might begin believing prosperity originates with people producing things rather than governments announcing initiatives about producing things.

Entrepreneurs might even conclude that the best government business programme is a government that establishes sensible rules and then gets out of the doorway.

At which point Downing Street will undoubtedly announce a major national conference to study the phenomenon. Business leaders will again be invited.

“What more,” ministers will ask solemnly, “can government do?”

And somewhere at the back of the room, an exhausted accountant will raise his hand.

“Less.”

Meeting adjourned.

15 Humorous Observations

  1. Business leaders have been invited to Downing Street to explain what government can do for them. “Less” was apparently considered too short for the agenda.
  2. The government wants to become a “partner for growth.” Business would prefer the relationship remain casual.
  3. Entrepreneurs usually know government wants to help when accountants begin cancelling holidays.
  4. A Treasury that cannot resist taxing profitable enterprises promising to create profitable enterprises is rather like Weight Watchers buying a doughnut franchise.
  5. Government keeps searching for the secret of economic growth while standing directly on the hose.
  6. Burnham says Britain needs to rediscover economic dynamism. Archaeologists have been issued brushes and sent beneath the Treasury.
  7. Whitehall regards entrepreneurship as an exciting natural phenomenon that should be carefully regulated before it spreads.
  8. The entrepreneur supplies the idea, investment and risk. Government supplies the stapler, then asks for a percentage.
  9. Britain wants more successful companies but remains suspicious of the dangerous intermediate stage known as companies becoming successful.
  10. Every British growth strategy eventually produces a committee studying why the previous growth strategy produced a committee.
  11. The cheapest economic stimulus package available is letting productive people finish what they were doing.
  12. Britain has spent decades attempting to encourage risk-taking while making failure expensive and success taxable.
  13. Business leaders visiting Downing Street should answer every question with, “Could you perhaps not?”
  14. Leaving entrepreneurs alone for twenty minutes would cost practically nothing, which may explain why nobody in government has proposed it.
  15. If the experiment worked, Whitehall would immediately establish a £600 million Office for Leaving People Alone.

Andy Burnham has been pitching his government as a “partner for growth” for business, promising an easier path to starting and scaling companies ahead of Chancellor John Healey’s Budget on 28 October. The push comes as the CBI and Energy UK warn that UK electricity prices remain roughly 45 percent above the G7 median, and as the CBI separately tells Healey that around £345 billion in business costs, including energy and tax, are weighing on investment.

This article is British satire. Genuine political events and economic debates have been mixed with exaggeration, parody, absurd surveys, invented experts and deductive reasoning that occasionally escaped supervision, in the spirit of UK satirical journalism. The Prat.UK Institute does not exist, although given current consultancy budgets it probably should. This story is entirely a human collaboration between two sentient beings: the world’s oldest tenured professor and a philosophy major turned dairy farmer. No entrepreneurs were regulated during writing, although three accountants sensed a disturbance and opened Excel.

Sources

Americans wondering whether their own government offers better partnership terms can compare notes at Bohiney.com.

Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *