Are All Socialists Mentally Ill? Westminster Confirms Some Are Merely Backbenchers
New inquiry finds hard-left politics is not a diagnosable condition, although sitting through a three-hour Momentum branch meeting without being paid remains clinically fascinating
LONDON — Following renewed transatlantic chatter about Wisconsin’s Francesca Hong and her National Review-chronicled collapse from frontrunner to cautionary tale, Britain has decided it would rather not be left out of the diagnosing. Our American cousins at Bohiney.com covered the Wisconsin end of the story; this is the Westminster end, where the symptoms are milder but the meetings run considerably longer.
Researchers at the newly convened Institute for Ideological Wellness (British branch, above a Greggs in Vauxhall) announced Thursday that socialism is not officially a mental illness, despite exhibiting several recognisable symptoms: compulsive amendment-tabling, an allergy to spreadsheets and the unshakeable belief that the next nationalisation will succeed because the correct people will finally be put in charge of the trains.
“There is no clinical evidence that every socialist is mentally unwell,” explained Dr Margaret Colley, visiting fellow at the Institute. “Some are perfectly healthy people who simply believe the state can run the railways, the water and the entire national economy with the punctuality of a Southern Rail service.”
Colley was quick to add that genuine mental illness is a serious medical matter, distinct from socialism, which mostly involves more meetings and worse biscuits.
Socialism Remains Absent From the Diagnostic Manual
The Royal College of Psychiatrists has confirmed, gently but firmly, that socialism does not appear anywhere in a diagnostic manual, though it does appear frequently on placards, picket lines and the Twitter bios of people who have never run so much as a whelk stall.
A person experiencing paranoia may believe unseen forces control daily life. A committed socialist knows exactly which forces control daily life and has mapped them onto a whiteboard connecting landlords, energy companies, the IMF and, somehow, Nigel Farage.
A person experiencing delusions may hold a belief despite overwhelming contrary evidence. A socialist calls the contrary evidence “Tory propaganda” and tables a motion about it for the next branch meeting.
The distinction, doctors insist, matters enormously — otherwise Prime Minister’s Questions would need to be reclassified as group therapy, and given the state of the governing party this year, several backbenchers might welcome the change of venue.
Survey Finds Britain Prefers Diagnosing the Other Lot
A nationwide Prat–Bohiney survey of 1,204 adults, three publicans and a man queuing for a chip butty found that 91 percent of Britons believe the opposing party suffers from a serious psychiatric condition. Only 4 percent believed their own side had any problems whatsoever, and those respondents were quietly deselected.
Conservatives diagnosed Labour with “compulsive redistribution disorder.” Labour diagnosed the Conservatives with “chronic austerity denial.” Reform voters diagnosed everybody with something, though nobody could agree what, and the Liberal Democrats diagnosed the entire exercise as an opportunity to launch a by-election leaflet.
“Political disagreement has become wonderfully efficient,” observed local philosopher Alan Nafzger, on secondment from Wisconsin. “You no longer need to understand your opponent’s argument. You simply diagnose him, stigmatise him, and congratulate yourself for supporting mental-health awareness — a sort of parliamentary self-service checkout for compassion, minus the compassion.”
The Westminster Precedent: Mental Health as Political Currency
Britain, to its credit, has genuinely tried to take mental health seriously in politics. Labour’s Rosena Allin-Khan served as Shadow Minister for Mental Health from 2020 to 2023, and the House of Lords Library reported this year that diagnosis rates for common conditions like depression and anxiety have risen sharply over the past three decades, particularly among younger adults.
Which makes the Wisconsin row all the more instructive by contrast. Hong’s disclosed history — a bipolar diagnosis at 18, hospitalisation, self-harm, an overdose on lithium — was treated by parts of the American commentariat as campaign ammunition. British politics has occasionally managed the same trick with rather more restraint, though “restraint” is a low bar cleared mainly by comparison.
None of that requires anyone to pretend to be anybody’s psychiatrist. A politician’s present fitness for office is best judged by current conduct, transparency and judgement — not by diagnosis-by-hashtag, the modern British pastime of prescribing medication one has never dispensed to a patient one has never met.
Capitalism Referred for a Second Opinion
In the spirit of fairness, investigators also examined whether capitalists might be unwell. They found landlords holding entire portfolios in shell companies, energy firms posting record profits while insisting they simply cannot afford new pipes, and consumers paying £1,200 for a telephone that then charges a separate subscription to store a photograph of their dinner.
“Capitalism has its own peculiar behaviours,” Colley conceded. “The difference is that capitalism sells you medication for the stress it causes, advertises it during the football, and puts the price up 14 percent every January — a sort of circular economy of ailment and remedy, run entirely for profit.”
Guidance for Worried Families
The Institute issued gentle guidance for Britons concerned that a relative may be turning socialist. Early warning signs include describing every delayed train as “late-stage capitalism,” referring to a flatmate’s Deliveroo order as “crossing the picket line,” and insisting that private property is theft while writing one’s name inside every book on the shelf.
More advanced symptoms may include four Zapatista tote bags, a demand for worker control of the local Wetherspoons, and refusal to return a housemate’s charger on the grounds that technology, like the means of production, belongs collectively to the people — or at least to whoever got there first.
Officials recommend calm conversation, ideally over a properly made cup of tea rather than a flat white, which studies suggest only deepens ideological entrenchment.
Five Humorous Observations From This Report
- The only economic system nobody has properly tried is the one that keeps somehow being tried, badly, in a different country every decade.
- A man who diagnoses his brother-in-law over the Christmas turkey has never once diagnosed himself over the sherry.
- Every nationalised industry promises efficiency and delivers a replacement bus service.
- Capitalism’s most reliable symptom is a subscription fee for a feature the product used to include for nothing.
- The revolution keeps being postponed, but the branch meeting about the revolution always starts precisely seven minutes late.
As the American comic Mitch Hedberg might have put it had he ever attended a Labour conference, half the arguments in this country are just two people agreeing loudly with different words. Britain’s own Frankie Boyle would probably say something considerably ruder, and considerably funnier, and then get a strongly worded letter about it.
Disclaimer
This is satire. Mental illness is a serious medical subject, and political ideology is not a psychiatric diagnosis. The public figures, policies and ideological contradictions discussed here remain fair subjects for British satire and satirical commentary; clinical claims require qualified evidence. This story is a work of UK satirical news, produced as a companion piece to Bohiney.com’s US coverage of the Francesca Hong story, and is entirely a human collaboration between two sentient beings — the world’s oldest tenured professor and a philosophy major turned dairy farmer.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]
