Spending Reviews, Fiscal Rules, OBR Forecasts, and the Department That Has the Final Word on Every Policy the Rest of Government Wants to Pursue
The Department That Says No: A Constitutional Portrait
In Whitehall, there are two kinds of government departments: HM Treasury, and departments that are waiting to find out what the Treasury will allow them to do. This is a slight exaggeration. It is also, to anyone who has worked in British central government, recognisable as a description that captures something essential about how policy is made, constrained, and occasionally strangled at birth in the United Kingdom.
The Treasury’s structural dominance of British economic and domestic policy is one of the most studied and least reformed features of the British state. It controls the public spending envelope, sets departmental budgets through the Spending Review process, adjudicates between competing departmental claims on resources, and simultaneously manages macroeconomic policy — a combination of functions that gives it influence over the direction of government that no other single department approaches. The Chancellor of the Exchequer is, in most governments, the second most powerful person in the Cabinet, and in some governments — Gordon Brown’s relationship with Tony Blair being the canonical example — a serious contender for first.
Fiscal Rules: The Self-Imposed Constraints That Each Government Invents, Breaks, and Replaces
Every Chancellor since Gordon Brown has operated under self-imposed fiscal rules — numerical targets for the deficit, debt, or public sector borrowing that are intended to provide credibility, constrain spending decisions, and demonstrate to markets that fiscal policy is not being set by electoral calculation. Each set of rules has been designed to be met by the government that set them. Several have not been met. All have been revised, redefined, or abandoned when meeting them became politically inconvenient, which is to say, most of them.
Brown’s Golden Rule — borrow only to invest, not current spending, over the economic cycle — was met partly by redefining the economic cycle at helpful moments. Osborne’s deficit reduction targets were missed in 2015 and quietly revised. Hammond’s rules survived until the pandemic made them irrelevant. Sunak’s rules were set, missed, reset, and then rendered academic by Truss’s forty-five day demolition of fiscal credibility. Rachel Reeves set new rules in 2024 and revised them within months of taking office following an inheritance that proved more challenging than pre-election accounts had suggested.
The Office for Budget Responsibility, established in 2010 to provide independent fiscal forecasts, has been the most significant institutional improvement in UK fiscal governance since Bank of England independence. Its forecasts constrain the Chancellor’s room to present optimistic numbers. Its assessments of fiscal rule compliance are independent of the Treasury’s own judgments. Its existence did not prevent the Truss mini-budget — which bypassed it entirely — but the immediate market response to a Budget without OBR forecasts was itself a demonstration of why the institution exists.
Spending Reviews: The Biennial Exercise in Managed Disappointment
The Spending Review is the process by which the Treasury allocates departmental budgets for the following three to five years. In theory, it is a rational allocation of resources based on need, priority, and efficiency. In practice, it is a negotiation between the Treasury and departmental ministers — each supported by their civil servants and economic advisers — in which the Treasury starts from a position of “less than you currently have” and departments start from a position of “considerably more than you’re offering,” and the outcome reflects the relative political weight of each department’s sponsor in the Cabinet, the Treasury’s assessment of what it can impose, and the proximity of the next election.
Health and education departments have historically been better protected than justice, local government, and transport departments, which reflects both genuine public priority and the relative political salience of their outputs. The consequence of differential protection over a decade of austerity is the pattern that the 2020s inherited: NHS and schools partially funded, courts backlogged and under-resourced, local councils cutting services to statutory minimum, and infrastructure investment consistently deferred in favour of current expenditure — a pattern that produces short-term fiscal numbers at long-term economic cost.
Treasury Culture and the Permanent Sceptic
Treasury officials occupy a specific cultural niche in Whitehall: highly intelligent, deeply sceptical of departmental spending claims, trained to identify the ways in which policy proposals will cost more than advertised and achieve less than promised, and institutionally oriented toward deficit reduction as the primary metric of fiscal virtue. This culture produces excellent analysis of why things cannot be done and is occasionally, critics suggest, less energetic in the analysis of what would happen if they were.
The Institute for Government’s analysis of Treasury dominance identifies the structural problem: a department responsible for both economic strategy and expenditure control has an inherent conflict between its growth objectives and its deficit reduction objectives, and tends to resolve it, under pressure, in favour of the short-term measurable (deficit) over the long-term contested (growth). This is rational institutional behaviour. It may not be optimal national economic policy. The two things are not the same.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
HM Treasury controls public expenditure through the Spending Review process, sets departmental budgets, and manages macroeconomic policy. The Office for Budget Responsibility, established in 2010, provides independent fiscal forecasts and assessments of fiscal rule compliance. The Chancellor of the Exchequer is typically the second most powerful member of Cabinet. Fiscal rules — numerical targets for deficit and debt — have been set, modified, and replaced by each Chancellor since Gordon Brown. The Truss-Kwarteng mini-budget of September 2022 notably bypassed the OBR, contributing to the gilt market crisis. The Institute for Government has documented Treasury dominance as a structural feature of British governance that affects policy outcomes across departments.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

London is the only city where the phrase “have a good one” is considered a deeply meaningful farewell that could mean anything from “see you later” to “I hope you never come back.”