Beveridge, Bevan, Austerity, Universal Credit, and the Ongoing Argument About What the State Owes Its Citizens
The Five Giants: Slain in 1948, Several Have Since Recovered
William Beveridge’s 1942 report — Social Insurance and Allied Services — identified five “giant evils” to be overcome by a reformed welfare state: Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor, and Idleness. The Attlee government of 1945-51 set about slaying them with a comprehensiveness and ambition that had not been seen in British social policy before and has not quite been replicated since: the National Insurance Act, the National Assistance Act, the National Health Service, the Education Act, and the mass council house building programme collectively established the architecture of the post-war welfare settlement.
Beveridge’s giants have not stayed slain. Want — poverty — affects approximately fourteen million people in the UK, including four million children, by the government’s own low-income measures. Disease is managed rather than conquered, with the NHS facing waiting lists of record length and a workforce crisis of considerable depth. Ignorance persists in the form of educational inequality that correlates strongly with parental income. Squalor is represented by a housing crisis that has produced house prices roughly nine times average earnings in many parts of England. Idleness has been replaced by in-work poverty — a category Beveridge’s framework was not designed to address, in which people work full time and cannot afford basic necessities.
The welfare state, in short, is less a finished achievement than an ongoing project — one that successive governments have maintained, reformed, cut, and restructured with sufficient regularity that its current form would be recognisable to Beveridge in its broad principles and alarming in many of its specifics.
The NHS: Beloved, Underfunded, and Never Far From Either a Crisis or an Election Campaign
The National Health Service is the welfare state’s most politically protected institution and its most administratively challenged. Founded by Aneurin Bevan in 1948 on the principle that healthcare should be free at the point of use and funded from general taxation, it has survived seventy-five years of reorganisation, underfunding, overpromising, and the periodic discovery that a health system serving sixty-seven million people requires considerably more money than the Treasury has historically been willing to provide.
The 2008 financial crisis and subsequent austerity programme produced the first sustained period of NHS real-terms funding decline in the institution’s history. The COVID-19 pandemic then imposed extraordinary demands on a system already under pressure. The resulting backlog — over seven million people waiting for treatment as of 2024, with some waiting years for procedures that would have taken weeks in 2010 — represents the accumulated consequence of a decade of underfunding meeting a once-in-a-generation public health emergency.
The NHS is also the political third rail of British politics: no mainstream party campaigns on reducing it, all parties campaign on improving it, and the gap between campaign promises and funding settlements has been consistent enough to constitute a structural feature rather than an occasional failure. The King’s Fund and the Health Foundation have produced decades of analysis demonstrating the relationship between NHS funding and outcomes. The political response to this analysis has been to commission further analysis.
Austerity: The Programme That Was Temporary and Lasted a Decade
The Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government of 2010 inherited a significant fiscal deficit — product of the 2008 financial crisis and the recession that followed — and responded with an austerity programme that reduced public spending across most departmental budgets over the following decade. The programme was presented as an economic necessity and disputed by many economists as a political choice; the empirical debate about whether deficit reduction at the speed pursued was required or whether it imposed unnecessary social costs has not been conclusively settled, partly because economic counterfactuals resist proof and partly because both sides of the debate have sufficient evidence to sustain their preferred conclusions.
The social consequences of austerity — documented by the Equality and Human Rights Commission, UN Special Rapporteur Philip Alston, and numerous academic studies — included rising child poverty, increased food bank usage, deterioration in disability support, local authority service cuts, and a measurable increase in mortality among some vulnerable populations attributable to care home and hospital funding reductions. The UN Special Rapporteur’s 2018 report described the situation as “a social calamity and an economic disaster” and was described by the government as “deeply flawed.” The data it contained was not disputed.
Housing: The Policy Failure That Both Parties Have Agreed to Fail At
The housing crisis — in which house prices have risen far beyond the reach of median earners, the private rental sector offers insecurity and poor quality at high cost, and the social housing stock is dramatically insufficient to meet demand — is one of the most persistent failures of British domestic policy. It is also one of the most politically intractable: high house prices benefit the majority of voters who own homes, while affecting most severely the minority who don’t, producing electoral incentives that are not obviously aligned with effective housing policy.
The planning system — through which new housing is approved — has been identified as a primary constraint on supply and reformed approximately every five years with approximately no net effect on the volume of homes built. The most recent reforms, pursued by the Starmer government, have reintroduced mandatory housing targets for local authorities and removed some of the blocking mechanisms that had reduced approvals. Whether this produces substantially more homes is the question that has been asked of every housing reform of the last thirty years, and answered, so far, in the negative.
The post-war council house building programme — which produced over a million homes in the early 1950s at its peak — has not been replicated. The Right to Buy scheme of the 1980s sold off council housing stock at a discount and the receipts were not recycled into replacement building. The social housing stock is now approximately half what it was in 1979, while demand has increased substantially. This is a policy outcome rather than a natural phenomenon, and it was produced by decisions — not to build, not to restrict Right to Buy, not to recycle receipts, not to mandate social housing in new developments — that were individually politically convenient and collectively produced a crisis.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
The British welfare state was established by the post-war Attlee government, drawing on Beveridge’s 1942 report identifying five giant evils: Want, Disease, Ignorance, Squalor, and Idleness. The NHS, founded in 1948 by Aneurin Bevan, remains the welfare state’s largest and most politically protected component. The 2010-2019 austerity programme reduced real-terms public spending across most departments, with documented social consequences. Universal Credit, consolidating six means-tested benefits, has been implemented since 2013 with significant delays and design problems. The housing crisis — with prices at roughly nine times average earnings in much of England — reflects decades of insufficient building and Right to Buy sales unreplaced by new social housing. Food bank usage has increased substantially since 2010, with the Trussell Trust reporting record parcel distributions.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

My wife asked why I was laughing so hard. I said “British people.” She nodded. Understanding.