Thatcher Wins Third Term, Opposition Wonders If There Is A Pattern Emerging
Voters Reward Stability by Doubling Down on It
Thatcher Wins Third Term, Opposition Wonders If There Is A Pattern Emerging
On 11 June 1987, Britain went to the polls for the third time in eight years and returned Margaret Thatcher to Downing Street with a majority of 102 smaller than the majority of 144 she had won in 1983 but larger than anything the Labour Party had managed since 1966, and sufficient to ensure that the third term would be conducted with the authority of a mandate that the opposition, for all its renewed energy and organisational improvement, had failed to dent in the ways that mattered.
The 1987 election was, from Labour’s perspective, an improvement on 1983 that was not an improvement enough. Neil Kinnock had spent four years rebuilding the party expelling the Militant Tendency, modernising the organisation, improving the presentation, producing a campaign of professional quality that generated genuine excitement at its launch and genuine disappointment at its conclusion. Labour won 229 seats, up from 209 in 1983. It was not enough. It was not close to enough. The Conservative majority was comfortable, the SDP-Liberal Alliance was again squeezed by the electoral system, and the pattern that had been emerging since 1979 had now emerged so completely that calling it a pattern was an understatement. It was an era.
The era of Thatcher had, by 1987, transformed British politics so thoroughly that the terms of debate had shifted in ways that made the Labour Party’s traditional arguments feel like dispatches from a country that no longer existed. The nationalisation programme that had been Labour policy in 1983 was gone. The unilateral nuclear disarmament policy that had been so electorally damaging was in the process of being abandoned. The trade union block vote was being managed rather than celebrated. Labour was becoming, slowly, reluctantly, and under considerable internal resistance, something different from what it had been a process that would take another ten years to complete and would eventually produce Tony Blair.
Kinnock: The Man Who Lost Well
Neil Kinnock had been elected Labour leader in October 1983, the youngest leader in the party’s history at forty-one, inheriting a party that had just experienced its worst defeat since 1935 and was conducting its grief through ideological argument of unusual intensity. He came from the Welsh valleys, from a mining community, from the Labour movement’s heartland, and he combined a genuine connection to that tradition with a political intelligence that told him, from fairly early in his leadership, that the party’s electability required transformation of a kind that the tradition was not going to find comfortable.
His 1985 conference speech the attack on Militant Tendency’s Liverpool councillors, the warning that their impossibilism was a betrayal of the people Labour existed to serve was the moment when the transformation announced itself publicly. The speech produced a standing ovation from the majority of the hall and furious objection from the Militant supporters, which is the precise response a party leader attempting to draw a line needs enough support to proceed, enough opposition to confirm that the line is being drawn in the right place.
By 1987, Kinnock had transformed Labour’s image considerably. The campaign designed by Peter Mandelson, inspired by Philip Gould’s polling analysis, and launched with a party political broadcast directed by Hugh Hudson that was more cinematic than anything British political advertising had previously attempted demonstrated that Labour had learned the lessons of presentation that the 1983 campaign had made available. The Sheffield rally of the final week, at which Kinnock’s well we’re alright! became the symbol of premature confidence, demonstrated that it had not quite learned all of them.
Wobbly Thursday and the Internal Crisis That Wasn’t
The most interesting episode of the 1987 Conservative campaign was not its triumphant conclusion but its mid-campaign crisis the period around the third week of campaigning when internal polling suggested that the Labour surge was real, that the majority was going to be substantially smaller than expected, and that the Conservatives’ private confidence was not matched by the public numbers.
Wobbly Thursday the day when Conservative Central Office absorbed the less comfortable of its own polling produced a recalibration of the campaign’s assumptions without producing a change in its fundamentals. Thatcher continued to campaign on the themes that had worked in 1979 and 1983 competence, economic management, the contrast between Conservative achievement and Labour’s record in government. The Labour surge, such as it was, proved insufficient. The majority of 102, while smaller than 1983, was comfortable.
The episode is remembered because it demonstrated that the Thatcher government was not immune to electoral anxiety that beneath the confidence and the conviction there was a political operation that watched its polling with the same nervous attention that all political operations bring to the numbers, and that adjusted its messaging accordingly. This is not a revelation exactly, but it is a humanising detail in a political career that the mythology of iron resolution tended to flatten.
What Eight Years of Thatcher Had Produced
By the election of 1987, the Britain that Thatcher had inherited in 1979 had been substantially transformed. Inflation, which had reached 22 percent in 1980, was running at 4 percent in 1987. Unemployment, which had peaked at over three million, was falling. The economy had been growing since 1981. The trade union movement had been legislatively constrained and industrially defeated. The nationalised industries were being privatised British Telecom in 1984, British Gas in 1986, British Airways in 1987 in programmes that transferred public assets to private ownership and, by the way, to the millions of small shareholders that the share offers were specifically designed to create.
The privatisation programme was, in economic terms, a mixed achievement some of the privatised industries became more efficient, competitive, and innovative; others became private monopolies that delivered the worst of both worlds private profit and public utility without the competitive discipline that was supposed to justify the transfer. British Telecom’s early years as a private company demonstrated that removing state ownership without creating a genuinely competitive market produced a company with the pricing power of a monopoly and the customer service instincts of an organisation that had not previously been required to regard customers as anything other than a captive resource.
The housing market had been transformed by the right-to-buy policy, which had allowed council tenants to purchase their homes at substantial discounts, creating a new class of homeowners and simultaneously reducing the stock of social housing in ways that would create pressure on the housing system for decades. The home-owning democracy that Thatcher had promised was, in 1987, more real than it had been in 1979. The supply of homes for those who could not afford to buy was considerably less real.
The SDP-Liberal Alliance: Still Breaking the Mould
The Alliance received 22.5 percent of the vote and won 22 seats a result that maintained the disproportion between its vote share and its parliamentary representation that the first-past-the-post system was reliably producing. The case for proportional representation, made with increasing urgency by Alliance politicians throughout the 1980s, was made most eloquently by the numbers themselves 22.5 percent of votes, 3.5 percent of seats and ignored with equal eloquence by the parties that the existing system was serving.
The Alliance would merge, imperfectly and contentiously, into the Liberal Democrats in 1988 a merger that Roy Jenkins supported, David Owen opposed, and Shirley Williams regarded as the pragmatically correct but emotionally complicated conclusion to the SDP experiment. The Liberal Democrats would inherit the Alliance’s structural problem with the electoral system and would carry it forward into the twenty-first century, winning their largest vote share in 2010 and entering government in coalition with the Conservatives, an outcome that resolved the electoral problem temporarily and the ideological problem not at all.
In 1987, however, the Alliance was still intact, still polling in the twenties, still claiming that the mould would break eventually, and still discovering that eventually is a very long time in British politics when the system is designed to produce a two-party outcome and both main parties are cooperating, with the quiet enthusiasm of self-interest, in producing it.
Thatcher won. Again. The voters had rewarded stability. Again. The opposition had improved. Again. The majority had shrunk. Again. The pattern, by this point, was clear. The question was not whether the pattern would continue but what would end it, and the answer which nobody in June 1987 was predicting correctly was not the electorate but the Cabinet.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
Margaret Thatcher won the 1987 general election on 11 June with a majority of 102 seats, her third consecutive election victory. Neil Kinnock had led Labour’s modernisation since his election as leader in October 1983, including his famous 1985 conference attack on Militant Tendency. Labour won 229 seats, up from 209 in 1983, but failed to make the gains required to threaten the Conservative majority. The SDP-Liberal Alliance received 22.5 percent of the vote and won 22 seats. The Conservatives’ Wobbly Thursday a period of internal polling anxiety mid-campaign produced adjustments to the campaign strategy without changing its outcome. The SDP and Liberal Party merged to form the Liberal Democrats in 1988. Thatcher resigned as Prime Minister in November 1990 following a leadership challenge.
ORIGINALY PUBLISHED: 11 June 1987 (London, UK)
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

My kid asked if people actually talk like this. I said “well I do now” and that’s the point.