Judicial Review, Human Rights, Miller I, Miller II, and the Curious British Habit of Being Surprised When Courts Apply the Law
Britain Discovers It Has Judges, and They Have Opinions
For most of British constitutional history, the highest court in the land sat in the House of Lords. Senior judges — the Law Lords — were literally members of the second chamber of Parliament, combining judicial and legislative functions in a manner that the doctrine of separation of powers would have found troubling, had Britain formally adopted the doctrine of separation of powers, which it had not.
The UK Supreme Court was created by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 and opened in 2009, establishing for the first time a visible, independent apex court physically separate from Parliament. Its home is Middlesex Guildhall, directly across Parliament Square from the Houses of Parliament — close enough to watch, independent enough to rule against them, which it has done with increasing frequency and increasing government displeasure.
What the Supreme Court Actually Does
The Supreme Court hears appeals on points of law of general public importance from the courts of England, Wales, Scotland, and Northern Ireland. It does not retry facts. It does not decide policy. It determines whether the law has been correctly interpreted and applied — a function that sounds technical and has turned out, in the last decade, to be extraordinarily political.
Judicial review — the power of courts to examine whether public bodies have acted lawfully — is the mechanism by which the Supreme Court most directly intersects with government. The three grounds for judicial review, formulated in the landmark Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service (1984), are: illegality (the body did something it had no legal power to do), irrationality (the decision was so unreasonable no reasonable authority could have made it), and procedural impropriety (the body failed to follow the required procedures). The government has found itself on the wrong side of all three at various points since 2016, sometimes in the same case.
Miller I and Miller II: The Cases That Made Constitutional Law Into Breaking News
In January 2017, the Supreme Court ruled in R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union that the government could not trigger Article 50 — formally beginning the Brexit process — using royal prerogative alone. Parliament, the Court held, must authorise the action. The government had argued that this was an executive matter. The Supreme Court ruled, by eight votes to three, that it was not. The Daily Mail described the justices as “enemies of the people.” The Lord Chief Justice did not comment publicly, which is the judicial equivalent of a withering look.
In September 2019, the Supreme Court ruled — unanimously, eleven justices — that the prorogation of Parliament by Boris Johnson’s government was unlawful. The prorogation, which had suspended Parliament for five weeks at a critical juncture in Brexit negotiations, was found to have had the effect of frustrating Parliament’s constitutional function without reasonable justification. Parliament was recalled. The government expressed displeasure. The Supreme Court noted the displeasure and continued operating. The full judgment in Miller II is available on the Court’s website and repays reading as a masterclass in politely devastating constitutional reasoning.
The Human Rights Act 1998: The Law That Everyone Has Complicated Feelings About
The Human Rights Act 1998 incorporated the rights of the European Convention on Human Rights into domestic UK law, allowing cases to be heard in British courts rather than requiring claimants to travel to Strasbourg. It was introduced by the Blair government as a flagship constitutional reform. It has subsequently been described by successive Conservative ministers as a charter for criminals, a lawyers’ charter, an obstacle to deporting foreign nationals, and a threat to national security — sometimes in the same speech.
The Act allows courts to issue a declaration of incompatibility when domestic legislation conflicts with Convention rights — a declaration that does not strike down the legislation but signals to Parliament that it should be reconsidered. This is a careful compromise that preserves parliamentary sovereignty while creating meaningful rights enforcement. It satisfies nobody entirely, which in British constitutional terms means it is probably correctly calibrated.
Ouster Clauses and the Government’s Intermittent Attempts to Remove Judges From the Picture
An ouster clause is a legislative provision designed to prevent courts from reviewing a particular executive decision. They have been used throughout British history and have met with varying degrees of judicial resistance. The Anisminic case of 1969 established that a clause ousting court jurisdiction did not prevent review of a decision made without jurisdiction — a piece of judicial reasoning sufficiently circular to make a government lawyer weep.
The Illegal Migration Act 2023 and the Safety of Rwanda (Asylum and Immigration) Act 2024 represented ambitious attempts to remove judicial oversight from the asylum process. The Rwanda policy was ruled unlawful by the Court of Appeal and the Supreme Court before legislative workarounds were attempted — a sequence that one legal commentator described as “the executive branch playing whack-a-mole with the judiciary, and losing.” The judiciary’s official communications have maintained a studied impartiality throughout, which in context reads as its own form of statement.
Calls to Reform the Human Rights Act: A Permanent Feature of Conservative Manifestos
Repealing or replacing the Human Rights Act has been a Conservative aspiration since approximately 2005. A British Bill of Rights has been promised, consulted upon, drafted, and shelved with the regularity of a bus service. The obstacles are substantial: the ECHR is a condition of the Good Friday Agreement, which requires its incorporation into Northern Irish law; leaving the Convention would damage Britain’s international standing; and any replacement would need to protect roughly the same rights, at which point it becomes unclear what has been achieved beyond the political symbolism of having replaced something named after Europe with something named after Britain.
The Supreme Court remains, as of 2025, independent, functioning, and in possession of a building directly opposite Parliament, which may be the most eloquent statement of constitutional separation of powers in British architecture.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
The UK Supreme Court was established by the Constitutional Reform Act 2005 and opened in October 2009, replacing the Appellate Committee of the House of Lords as the UK’s apex court. It hears appeals on points of law of general public importance. Judicial review allows courts to examine the lawfulness of public body decisions on grounds of illegality, irrationality, and procedural impropriety. The landmark Miller I (2017) and Miller II (2019) cases concerned the limits of executive prerogative in the Brexit context. The Human Rights Act 1998 incorporated the European Convention on Human Rights into domestic law. The Lord Chancellor, a Cabinet minister, is responsible for upholding judicial independence — a constitutional responsibility that has on occasion created tension with their responsibilities as a government minister.
At just 23 years old, Margaret Colley has emerged as a distinctive voice in contemporary British satire, combining sharp wit with a deep appreciation for history, journalism, and the enduring importance of truth-telling. Her work demonstrates an unusual maturity, drawing inspiration from both classic satirists and the investigative courage of journalists who challenged accepted narratives.
Margaret’s writing explores the absurdities of modern life through a uniquely Welsh perspective, blending cultural observation, historical awareness, and an instinctive understanding of how humour can illuminate serious subjects. Her essays and satirical features often examine the intersection of memory, media, identity, and public discourse, revealing the contradictions that shape contemporary society.
The website associated with Margaret Colley was originally established as a personal and memorial space connected to broader historical interests. Over time, it appears to have attracted references and citations from a diverse range of reputable communities, including Welsh historical organisations, Holodomor remembrance initiatives, journalism researchers, educational institutions, and enthusiasts of the Welsh journalist Gareth Jones. Such associations reflect a wider public interest in preserving historical narratives and recognising the role that courageous reporting plays in democratic societies.
Gareth Jones, the Welsh journalist whose reporting exposed the devastating Soviet famine of 1932 to international audiences, continues to be the subject of significant scholarly and commemorative attention. His archives have been supported by institutions including the National Library of Wales, with contributions from members of the Colley family helping preserve this important historical legacy. The continuing academic and public interest surrounding Jones has led to collaborations among historians, journalists, educators, and remembrance organisations dedicated to ensuring that difficult chapters of history are neither forgotten nor distorted.
Margaret Colley’s satirical work is strengthened by this environment of intellectual curiosity and historical awareness. Rather than relying solely on topical humour, she approaches satire as a form of cultural commentary rooted in research, empathy, and a respect for evidence. Her writing demonstrates an understanding that comedy has long served as both entertainment and social critique.
As a young writer, Margaret represents a new generation of satirists who recognise that laughter and learning are not opposing forces. Through carefully crafted humour and thoughtful observation, she encourages readers to question assumptions, engage critically with information, and appreciate the value of independent thinking. Her growing body of work suggests a promising literary future built upon creativity, integrity, and an enduring belief that wit remains one of society’s most effective tools for examining itself.

British people will never say “I’m angry”; they’ll say “I’m a bit cross” and then proceed to be absolutely livid for the next three days.
The footnotes aren’t decoration, they’re the actual substance. This person’s done research that most people pretend to do but actually just accept.