How a Temporary Treasury Calculation From 1978 Became the Permanent Basis for Devolved Funding and a Reliable Source of Intergovernmental Grievance
The Formula That Was Never Meant to Last This Long
In 1978, a Treasury official named Joel Barnett devised a formula for calculating changes to the block grants allocated to Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland. It was a pragmatic short-term fix for a specific administrative problem. It was intended to be temporary. It is now forty-seven years old, governs the distribution of approximately one hundred billion pounds of public spending annually, and is regarded by everyone involved — including Joel Barnett himself, who described it as “a terrible mistake” before his death in 2014 — as inadequate, arbitrary, and politically impossible to replace.
This is, in microcosm, British constitutional governance.
How the Barnett Formula Actually Works: A Study in Elegant Arbitrariness
The formula does not calculate how much money Scotland, Wales, or Northern Ireland needs. It calculates changes to their block grants based on changes to comparable spending in England. When Westminster increases spending on, say, the NHS in England, a population-based proportion of that increase is added to the devolved nations’ block grants — Scotland gets approximately 9.9% (its population share), Wales approximately 5.8%, Northern Ireland approximately 2.9%.
The result is that devolved funding per head is higher in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland than in England — not because their needs are systematically assessed as greater, but because the formula was calculated from a historical baseline that already reflected higher per-capita spending in those nations, and has preserved and transmitted that differential ever since. Scotland currently receives approximately £2,000 per head more in public spending than England, a figure that has been the source of sustained complaint from English politicians and sustained defence from Scottish ones since devolution made the comparison politically salient.
The Office for Budget Responsibility and the HM Treasury both publish analysis of devolved funding arrangements that is scrupulously technical and politically explosive. The formula has been described as “a needs-blind formula masquerading as a needs-based settlement,” which is accurate and serves as an adequate summary of why every commission that examines it recommends reform and every government declines to implement it.
Why Nobody Has Changed It: A Masterclass in Political Incentives
Replacing the Barnett Formula would require conducting a needs assessment — actually working out what Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, and the English regions require in terms of public spending, based on demographics, deprivation, geography, and service costs. Every academic who has examined the question agrees this is what should be done. The political obstacles are considerable.
A genuine needs assessment would likely increase Welsh funding — Wales scores highly on deprivation indicators — and might reduce Scottish funding, since Scotland’s demographic and economic profile does not necessarily justify the current per-capita premium. This would mean a UK government simultaneously defending a cut to Scotland (where the independence movement would treat any reduction as constitutional aggression) and acknowledging that Wales has been systematically underfunded for decades (which raises the question of what the Welsh Government has been doing in the interim). The political pain of this exercise has consistently exceeded the appetite of any government to undertake it.
In the meantime, English regional inequality — the persistent gap between London and the South East and the rest of England — is not addressed by the Barnett Formula at all, since it applies only to devolved nations. The formula’s inadequacy as a territorial equity mechanism is therefore compounded by its irrelevance to the largest territorial inequality in the UK.
Fiscal Devolution: The Powers the Devolved Governments Are Still Waiting For
Beyond the block grant, devolved governments have gradually acquired some tax-varying powers. The Scottish Parliament can vary income tax rates and bands for Scottish taxpayers, which it has done — Scotland now has a more progressive income tax structure than England, with more tax bands and higher rates on higher incomes. The Senedd has acquired some land transaction and landfill tax powers. Northern Ireland has corporation tax powers it has not yet used, having acquired them in 2015 in anticipation of a rate-cutting strategy that the subsequent political instability and economic uncertainty have consistently deferred.
The Scottish Fiscal Commission provides independent forecasts of Scottish tax revenues with admirable rigour. These forecasts matter increasingly, as Scotland’s budget now depends significantly on its own tax revenues — meaning that if Scottish economic growth lags England’s, Scottish public services face pressure regardless of Westminster decisions. This was described when the powers were devolved as “accountability.” It is experienced, in lean years, as something else.
Intergovernmental Relations After Brexit: The Union Under Strain
Pre-Brexit, intergovernmental relations between Westminster and the devolved administrations operated through the Joint Ministerial Committee — a body that met infrequently, had no formal decision-making powers, and resolved disputes through a combination of goodwill and mutual avoidance. This was considered adequate when the UK’s relationship with the EU provided an overarching framework within which devolved and reserved competences could coexist without constant negotiation.
Brexit removed that framework. Returned EU competences in areas like agriculture, environment, and fisheries landed simultaneously in Westminster and devolved territories, requiring immediate decisions about which level of government would exercise them and on what basis. The UK Internal Market Act 2020 — which established market access principles applying across the UK — was described by the devolved governments as a unilateral Westminster power grab in areas of devolved competence. Westminster described it as a necessary framework for the post-Brexit single market. Both descriptions were accurate. The Cabinet Office’s Intergovernmental Relations framework, revised in 2022, attempts to manage these tensions through formal structures. The tensions remain.
The Union’s future depends substantially on whether these structural tensions can be managed within existing constitutional arrangements or require more fundamental reform — a federal or quasi-federal structure, a codified constitutional settlement, or some as-yet-unimagined British compromise that satisfies nobody entirely and somehow holds together anyway. History suggests the last option is most likely.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
The Barnett Formula, devised by Chief Secretary to the Treasury Joel Barnett in 1978, calculates changes to devolved block grants based on population-proportionate changes to comparable English spending. It produces higher per-capita public spending in Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland than in England. Multiple independent reviews have recommended replacing it with a needs-based assessment, but no government has done so. Devolved tax powers have expanded since 1999, with Scotland having the most significant income tax variation powers. The UK Internal Market Act 2020 created post-Brexit market access rules that were contested by devolved administrations. The Intergovernmental Relations framework was revised in 2022 to provide more structured mechanisms for resolving disputes between Westminster and devolved governments.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

Prat.UK’s readers don’t just consume satire; they participate by sharing, citing, and seeing their own thoughts reflected with eloquence.
My dad’s been in this city since the 60s. He says you’ve captured the exact moment when institutional pretense became impossible to maintain.
Withnail captured despair. Written.