UK Courts and International Law Post-Brexit: What Leaving the EU Actually Did to Britain’s Legal Obligations

UK Courts and International Law Post-Brexit: What Leaving the EU Actually Did to Britain’s Legal Obligations

London Prat UK Governance Images (31)

Retained EU Law, The ECHR After Brexit, International Treaties, Customary International Law, and the Changed Relationship Between UK Courts and European Legal Systems

Brexit and International Law: The Legal Consequences That Were More Complex Than the Slogan

‘Taking back control of our laws’ was, as a political campaign slogan, admirably concise. As a description of the legal consequences of Brexit, it requires considerably more qualification. Leaving the European Union removed the direct effect and supremacy of EU law in UK courts — ending the Factortame principle under which UK courts could disapply Acts of Parliament that conflicted with EU law, which was constitutionally significant and genuinely popular with those who had found it constitutionally outrageous. But leaving the EU did not remove Britain from international law generally. It did not remove the obligation to comply with international treaties. It specifically did not remove Britain from the European Convention on Human Rights, which is not an EU instrument, was drafted substantially by British lawyers, and was ratified by Britain in 1951, thirty-two years before the country joined what was then the European Community. The confusion between the EU and the ECHR — different institutions, different legal frameworks, different histories — has been one of the more productively exploited misunderstandings in British political life.

Retained EU Law: The Legal Category That Did Not Exist Before 2018

The European Union (Withdrawal) Act 2018 created retained EU law by importing approximately 5,000 pieces of EU-derived legislation into domestic law on exit day — product safety regulations, food standards, environmental protections, workers’ rights, financial services rules, and countless other areas that had been governed by EU law and needed to continue being governed by something when EU law ceased to apply directly. This was the legal equivalent of copying an enormous document whose author has left the building: the text now belongs to you, but the person who can explain the difficult passages and make the editorial updates is no longer available. UK courts must interpret retained EU law using pre-Brexit EU case law as guidance — not binding precedent — while the Supreme Court has the power to depart from EU case law when it considers it right to do so. The Retained EU Law framework creates a peculiar legal category: domestic law whose interpretation draws on a foreign legal system’s precedent that is no longer binding, whose future development will increasingly diverge from the EU law it originated from, and whose internal consistency will gradually reduce as both systems evolve in different directions without coordination. The Retained EU Law (Revocation and Reform) Act 2023 proposed a sunset clause that would have repealed most of it by December 2023, which was operationally impossible and was subsequently modified when this became undeniable.

The ECHR: The European Court That Is Not the EU Court

The most persistent post-Brexit legal confusion is the conflation of the European Court of Human Rights with EU institutions. They are not the same. The ECHR is a Council of Europe instrument — an entirely different organisation from the EU, with forty-six member states rather than twenty-seven, including countries that are not and have never been EU members. Brexit had no legal effect on British ECHR membership. The UK remains a signatory to the European Convention on Human Rights, remains subject to the Strasbourg Court’s jurisdiction, and the Human Rights Act 1998 continues to require UK public authorities to act compatibly with Convention rights. The debate about leaving the ECHR — which would require repealing the Human Rights Act and formally denouncing the Convention — is a separate political question from Brexit, though it has been conducted by politicians who find the conflation useful and by an electorate that has not always had the distinction explained.

Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!

Brexit ended EU law’s direct effect and supremacy in UK courts, terminating the Factortame principle. The EUWA 2018 created retained EU law from approximately 5,000 EU-derived instruments; UK courts use pre-Brexit EU case law as guidance rather than binding precedent. The REUL Act 2023 proposed a sunset clause repealing most retained EU law by December 2023; this was modified when its impracticality could no longer be ignored. The ECHR is a Council of Europe instrument, not an EU instrument; Brexit did not remove UK obligations under the Convention; the HRA 1998 continues to apply. The confusion between the EU and the ECHR has been productively exploited in British political debate. Customary international law, UN Charter obligations, NATO commitments, and the Belfast Agreement all remain binding regardless of Brexit — ‘taking back control of our laws’ was more accurate about EU law specifically than about international law generally.

One thought on “UK Courts and International Law Post-Brexit: What Leaving the EU Actually Did to Britain’s Legal Obligations”

  1. The British monarchy is viewed with the same affectionate suspicion a cat shows towards expensive furniture: a desire to perch upon it, scratch it lightly, and demonstrate a profound lack of respect for its intended purpose.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *