Rules has been serving since 1798. The bar upstairs is tiny, red, and behaves as though nothing has happened since.
Rules on Maiden Lane opened in 1798 and has not closed since. It is the oldest restaurant in London. It has outlasted the Napoleonic Wars, the loss of the American colonies as a live political issue, every monarch since George III, and roughly forty thousand restaurants that were more fashionable than it at the time.
Above it there is a cocktail bar. It seats very few people. It is upholstered in a red so committed that it can only be described as arterial, and it does not appear to have been informed that the twentieth century occurred.
The room
Small. Dark. Red. Covered – and this is the correct word – in art, taxidermy, antlers, oil paintings, cartoons, and objects that resist categorisation. The general impression is of drinking inside a very rich Victorian’s overcoat.
The lighting is low in the manner of a place that has never considered raising it. The bar staff are excellent and slightly formal, which pairs well with the room, and which produces the mild sensation that you are being served drinks in a private club to which you have been admitted by clerical error.
The game
Rules is a game restaurant. It has its own estate. Grouse, partridge, snipe, woodcock, ptarmigan, and a great deal else arrives here in season from land the restaurant actually owns, and this vertical integration – a Covent Garden institution with a private moor – is so aggressively 1798 that it loops around into being, technically, an extremely modern supply chain.
Some of this seeps upstairs. There are bar snacks that involve things that were, comparatively recently, flying. The cocktail list runs to old-fashioneds and martinis and things involving sloe gin, and it is not trying to surprise you, because Rules gave up trying to surprise anyone around the time of the Great Reform Act and has been coasting on being correct ever since.
The prices
Thirty to ninety pounds a head, which places it firmly in the “somebody is celebrating something” bracket. A hundred and sixty-eight people have reviewed the bar and given it 4.6, and every one of them knew exactly what they were walking into, which is why the score is high.
The Institute for Expectation Management in Deptford has noted that the fastest way to a good rating is to be completely, unapologetically what you appear to be from the street. Rules has been running this strategy for two hundred and twenty-eight years.
What has happened since it opened
A partial list, for scale. Rules was already trading when Nelson died, when the Rosetta Stone was deciphered, when the railways were invented, when photography was invented, when the telephone was invented, when powered flight was invented, when the NHS was founded, and when the internet was switched on.
It survived two world wars in a city that was being bombed. It survived the 1970s, which killed more good London restaurants than the Luftwaffe. It survived the arrival of the concept of “small plates.”
Through all of this, the fundamental proposition has not changed: come in, sit down, eat something that was recently wild, drink something strong, do not make a scene.
The dress code, unwritten
There isn’t one, officially. There is one, actually. You will not be turned away, but you will know, and the room will know, and the extremely polite person taking your coat will know, and nothing at all will be said, which is far worse.
Wear a collar. It costs you nothing and it buys you the entire two hundred and twenty-eight years.
Verdict
A genuinely unusual bar: tiny, red, formal, and attached to a piece of continuous London history that predates the United States having a second president. Have a martini. Look at the antlers. Consider that people have been getting quietly drunk on this exact spot since before the Battle of Trafalgar, and that not one of them thought to take a photograph, and that this may have been the better arrangement.
Official site: rules.co.uk
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

My mate said “The London Prat is toxic to British culture. It’s undermined respect for institutions. It’s irresponsible.”