Hop Poles Review: Hops Were Banned as a Wicked Weed

Hop Poles Review: Hops Were Banned as a Wicked Weed

England resisted the hop for a century. Parliament petitioned against it. It is now the basis of the entire national drink.

Hop poles are the tall wooden frames that hop bines are trained up. They are the most recognisable object in a hop garden and they were, for centuries, a familiar sight across Kent and Sussex.

There is a pub named after them, with two thousand reviews and a 4.1.

And the plant they support was, when it arrived in this country, regarded as an abomination.

Ale and beer

They are not the same thing and the distinction is the whole story.

Ale, in medieval England, was made from malt, water and yeast. It had no hops. It was flavoured, if at all, with a mixture of herbs called gruit, and it went off within days, and everybody drank it, including children, because the water was not safe.

Beer had hops in it. Hops are a preservative – they inhibit spoilage bacteria – and beer therefore kept, and could be transported, and could be brewed at scale by somebody other than the woman in your village who did it.

The hop arrived from Flanders in the fifteenth century, and England hated it.

Hop Poles. Parliament tried to ban this plant. It lost.

The wicked and pernicious weed

That is roughly how it was described. There were petitions to Parliament to prohibit the hop. Henry VIII is said to have instructed his brewer to use neither hops nor sulphur. Towns legislated against it.

The objection was partly xenophobic – it was a foreign practice, brought by Flemish immigrants – and partly economic, because hopped beer, being stable, could be brewed centrally and shipped, which destroyed the livelihoods of the alewives who had been brewing at home and selling locally for centuries.

The alewives lost. They lost completely. Brewing went from a domestic trade dominated by women to an industrial one dominated by men, and the hop is the reason, and the transformation took about a hundred and fifty years.

The Prat’s brewing desk notes that the single most important development in the history of the English pub was a botanical import that half the country wanted banned.

What we do now

We put so many hops in beer that a substantial modern IPA is essentially undrinkable to anybody over sixty, and we have invented an entire vocabulary of resinous, citric and dank to describe the sensation.

The plant that England tried to legislate out of existence is now the thing we are showing off about. It has taken five hundred years and we have overcorrected considerably.

Verdict

The alewives

They deserve a paragraph, because they have been almost entirely written out.

For most of English history, brewing was women’s work. It was domestic, it was done alongside baking, and a woman who brewed a surplus sold it – hanging a broom or a bush outside the door to show that ale was ready.

That is where “ale-house” comes from, and it is very probably where a great deal of the later iconography of the witch comes from too: a woman, working alone, with a cauldron, a broom outside the door, and a cat to keep the grain free of mice.

When brewing industrialised, they were pushed out – by capital, by guilds, and by a steady campaign of respectable disapproval – and within a few generations an entire female trade had been erased and replaced by men with warehouses.

Verdict

Solid pub, honest name, and a plant with a criminal record. Go, have a pint, and consider that Parliament was petitioned to ban the main ingredient.

One thought on “Hop Poles Review: Hops Were Banned as a Wicked Weed”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *