Carpenter’s Arms Review: The Guild Owned the Trade and You Could Not Work Without It

Carpenter’s Arms Review: The Guild Owned the Trade and You Could Not Work Without It

Seven years’ apprenticeship, a monopoly enforced by law, and the compasses are on the sign

The Carpenter’s Arms holds a 4.5 from six hundred and eighty reviews, charges ten to twenty pounds, and the arms in the name are a real coat of arms, belonging to a real and still-existing body.

The Worshipful Company of Carpenters

Which is a livery company – one of the ancient guilds of the City of London – and it is still there.

And its arms carry compasses.

Which is why the Goat and Compasses is very probably a goat and a carpenter’s badge, and not a mangled piece of scripture, whatever the internet says.

The Carpenters. A guild. You could not practise the trade without it.

What a guild actually was

Which is usually described as a charity with a nice hall, and which was nothing of the kind.

A guild was a monopoly.

It controlled who was allowed to practise the trade in the city – and if you were not a member, you could not work, and it was enforced.

And it controlled entry

Through the apprenticeship – which was typically seven years.

And an apprentice was bound by a legal indenture. He lived in the master’s house. He was not paid a wage. He could not marry. He could be beaten.

And at the end of it he was a journeyman – from the French journee, a day, because he was paid by the day.

And only after that, and after producing a masterpiece – which is what the word means, and it is a literal test piece submitted for judgement – might he become a master.

Which was a closed shop

And the Prat’s editorial desk is going to be even-handed about this, because the guilds get both too much praise and too much abuse.

They enforced quality – because a bad carpenter damaged the reputation of every carpenter, and because the buyer cannot check.

You do not know a badly built roof until it falls on you.

Wherever the buyer cannot check the product, somebody has to – and if nobody does, the market fills with poison.

And they were also, unarguably, a cartel – restricting entry, keeping prices up, and excluding outsiders, women, and foreigners with considerable energy.

Both of those things are true, and neither cancels the other.

Which is the finding

Eight postcodes and thirteen hundred and three articles.

The interesting thing happens where the rent is cheap and the authorities are not looking – and a guild is the authorities, looking.

Which is why a new medium has no incumbents – and why three East End boys took over British fashion photography in the sixties, and why the door closed behind them within twenty years, once there were courses in it.

And they are still there

Which is the strangest part.

Because the livery companies of the City of London still exist – all of them – and they still have halls, and dinners, and a Master.

And they are now, very largely, charitable and educational bodies. They fund schools. They give scholarships. They award prizes.

The monopoly is gone. The building is still there. The name is still there.

The container survives. The contents do not.

Verdict

Excellent, cheap, strong number.

2 thoughts on “Carpenter’s Arms Review: The Guild Owned the Trade and You Could Not Work Without It”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *