Downstairs at Sucre Review: Sugar Built Half This City

Downstairs at Sucre Review: Sugar Built Half This City

And the name is French for it, and the restaurant is Argentine, and the word has been very quiet about what it did

Downstairs at Sucre has eighty-nine reviews and a 4.5, charges ten to twenty pounds, and it is the basement bar of an Argentine restaurant.

And the word over the door means sugar.

What sugar did

We wrote about this at the Sugar Loaf, in the City, and it does not get less true.

Sugar was the single most profitable commodity in the Atlantic world, and it was grown, cut, milled and boiled by enslaved people, in conditions that killed them at a rate which required the trade to be continuously replenished.

That is not a footnote and it is not a modern reading. It is the economic basis of the entire business, it was understood at the time, and it built a very substantial part of the wealth of this city.

The Jamaica Wine House, in the City, stands on the site of London’s first coffee house – and it became the Jamaica Coffee House, and it appears in eighteenth-century newspapers as the address to reply to regarding escaped enslaved people.

Sucre. It means sugar. That word did a great deal.

The teeth

One consequence, because it is the one that shows up in the bones.

Elizabeth I’s teeth were black, and the reason was sugar – she had access to it in quantities almost nobody else did, and a German visitor recorded the effect and noted that the English seemed to suffer from it generally, on account of their excessive use of it.

And black teeth briefly became fashionable. Women who could not afford sugar are reported to have blackened their teeth deliberately, to look as though they could.

A status symbol so powerful that people imitated the damage.

Sucre the city

Which is the other reading, and which is probably the one intended.

Sucre is the constitutional capital of Bolivia, named after Antonio Jose de Sucre – a general of the wars of independence, one of Bolivar’s closest lieutenants, and the man who won the battle of Ayacucho, which effectively ended Spanish rule in South America.

He became the first president of Bolivia. He resigned after two years, worn out by the politics, and was assassinated in a forest at the age of thirty-five.

His name means sugar, in French, and it is a coincidence, and it has nothing to do with anything.

Six hundred and thirty-nine articles, and we have learned to check.

The basement

Which is where the good rooms in London are, and we have said this in every district.

Coal vaults. Banking halls. Victorian lavatories. Port cellars. Meat market vaults. A car park.

None of them were built for drinking, and all of them are better than the ones that were.

Verdict

Excellent little bar, small sample, and a name that could mean a Bolivian general or the most consequential crop in the history of the Atlantic.

The Argentine part

Which is what you are actually eating, and which is worth the trip.

Beef, over embers – and we explained the difference at Ember Yard. A flame carbonises. An ember radiates. And every serious grill cook in the world builds the fire in one place and cooks somewhere else.

The asado is the same principle: coals, time, salt, and nothing else. No marinade, no sauce, no rub.

And the cut you want is not the fillet. It is the one with fat on it, because the fat is where the flavour is, and the British have spent forty years ordering the leanest thing on the menu and then complaining that it tasted of nothing.

One thought on “Downstairs at Sucre Review: Sugar Built Half This City”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *