The second-largest sample in five postcodes, at one of the highest scores, and the explanation is not complicated
Scarlett Green on Noel Street holds a 4.8 from eleven thousand two hundred and sixty-nine people, and charges twenty to thirty pounds.
It is the second-largest sample in five postcodes – behind only Amalfi, up the road, which holds a 4.8 from fifteen thousand – and it is doing exactly the same thing.
The pattern is now unmistakable
Two venues. Two enormous samples. Two 4.8s. Both in Soho. Both a few streets apart.
And both of them are doing something that our own iron law says should be impossible, because ratings decay with volume and always have.
So we have to explain it, and the explanation is not complicated and it is not flattering to the rest of the industry.
They are not promising anything
That is the whole answer.
Amalfi promises a good Italian dinner at a fair price, near Oxford Circus, quickly.
Scarlett Green promises an Australian brunch, done well, in a bright room, at a reasonable price.
Neither of them is chasing a star. Neither has a rope, a hidden door, a Prohibition premise, a Victorian explorer, or a concept of any kind. Neither is trying to be an experience.
And we have spent five hundred and fifty-eight articles establishing that the star rating measures the gap between what somebody expected when they pushed the door and what they got.
Set the expectation low and precise. Clear it every time. Do it eleven thousand times.
That is the entire method and essentially nobody in the trade is using it, because it does not feel like ambition.
The Australians, again
Who we have now met in three postcodes and who have comprehensively colonised the British morning.
They fixed the coffee. That is not a small claim and it is not disputed – the flat white, the espresso culture, the assumption that a cafe should be able to make a decent coffee at all, are Antipodean imports of the last twenty-five years.
And they brought brunch, which Britain accepted with considerably less enthusiasm and considerably more queueing.
We noted at Beany Green and at Sunday in Brooklyn that between the Australian and American invasions, this country can no longer eat a fried egg on a Saturday without booking, queueing, or being photographed.
Verdict
Excellent, cheerful, extremely busy, and one of the two best numbers in five postcodes.
Go early. Everybody else is already there.
The two-hundred-review question
Somebody will ask, so we will answer it.
Can a venue buy eleven thousand reviews? No. Not at this scale and not with this consistency – the platforms are not perfect but they are not that bad, and a coordinated campaign of that size leaves patterns that are visible.
What a venue can do is ask. A polite prompt at the end of a meal, from a member of staff, to a customer who has had a nice time, converts at a genuinely significant rate – and it selects, gently, for the people who enjoyed themselves.
That is not fraud. It is a nudge, and every large operator in this survey is doing it, and the ones with the biggest samples are doing it best.
The number is real. The sample is not random. Both of those are true.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

A teacher used LONDON PRAT to explain institutional failure to her students. They understood governance better than most government officials.
British people invented saying true things while maintaining complete deniability. This violates that tradition refreshingly.