Parliamentary Sovereignty: Parliament Can Do Anything Except Understand What It’s Doing

Parliamentary Sovereignty: Parliament Can Do Anything Except Understand What It’s Doing

London Prat UK Governance Images (27)

The Supreme Legal Principle That Allows Parliament to Pass Any Law, Including Laws About How Supreme It Is

Parliamentary Sovereignty: Parliament Can Do Anything Except Understand What It’s Doing

The Supreme Legal Principle That Allows Parliament to Pass Any Law, Including Laws About How Supreme It Is

A.V. Dicey, the nineteenth-century constitutional lawyer whose 1885 work remains required reading for anyone who wants to understand British government or needs help sleeping, identified parliamentary sovereignty as the “dominant characteristic of our political institutions.” The principle is deceptively simple: Parliament can make or unmake any law, and no court can override a valid Act of Parliament. Parliament is, legally speaking, omnipotent. This is either tremendously reassuring or deeply alarming, depending on how much confidence you place in the 650 people currently in the House of Commons to wield omnipotence responsibly. History suggests: inconsistently, with occasional flashes of brilliance surrounded by long stretches of mediocrity and several notable disasters.

The Logical Paradox: Can Parliament Bind Its Successors?

If Parliament can do anything, can it bind future Parliaments? If Parliament passes a law saying “no future Parliament may repeal this,” is that law valid? Constitutional lawyers have spent over a century on this question and reached, broadly, the conclusion that it’s complicated — a technical term meaning “nobody fully agrees and we’ve all built careers on the ambiguity.” The working answer is that Parliament cannot bind its successors, because sovereignty means each Parliament is equally supreme. This sounds tidy until you reach the Human Rights Act 1998, which required courts to interpret legislation compatibly with Convention rights “so far as possible.” Parliament passed this. Courts have used it to issue declarations of incompatibility with Acts of Parliament. Parliament is technically free to ignore these declarations. Parliament has largely not — because the political cost of publicly ignoring a court ruling that your law violates human rights is, even for this Parliament, quite high. The convention that Parliament acts on declarations of incompatibility is unwritten, legally unenforceable, and has held consistently. This is British constitutionalism in its purest form: technically unlimited, practically constrained by embarrassment.

The Elected Dictatorship Problem

Lord Hailsham coined the phrase “elective dictatorship” in 1976 to describe the concentration of power that parliamentary sovereignty creates with a strong majority government and a flexible constitution. With no written constitution, no codified rights, and a first-past-the-post system that frequently produces large majorities from minority vote shares, a British government with a working majority can quite legally pass almost anything it wants. Hailsham coined this phrase when Labour was in power. When his own party achieved a landslide majority in 1983, his concerns became notably quieter — which is itself a magnificent demonstration of the principle. The London Prat calls this “sovereignty amnesia: the selective forgetting of constitutional principle upon gaining a majority.” The checks that exist on parliamentary power are political, conventional and cultural rather than legal. What remains is elections, the press, public opinion, and the collective judgment of the people’s representatives — which is either a profound trust in democracy or an extraordinary leap of faith. On most given days in Westminster it is genuinely difficult to tell which. Explore the omnipotence problem at Bohiney’s complete explainer on institutions that keep surprising themselves. Newsthump covers the daily evidence.

SOURCE: https://bohiney.com

3 thoughts on “Parliamentary Sovereignty: Parliament Can Do Anything Except Understand What It’s Doing”

  1. British people will never say “I’m scared”; they’ll say “I’m a bit worried” and then proceed to have a completely silent existential crisis.

  2. A man said “My partner uses The London Prat to justify not trying anymore. She’s given up on improvement. It’s draining.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *