Belle Livingstone’s 58th Street Country Club, Peckham

Belle Livingstone’s 58th Street Country Club, Peckham

A Peckham dining room named after a real Prohibition speakeasy queen who kept goldfish, indoor mini-golf and a very relaxed attitude to the Volstead Act

Most bars borrow their glamour from a font. Belle Livingstone’s 58th Street Country Club borrows hers from an actual person, and the Prat’s naming desk is pleased to report that the person in question fully earned the marquee. This Peckham venue is an immersive dining and theatre production by The Lost Estate, recreating a 1930s New York super-speakeasy – and unlike most themed nights out, the theme is load-bearing history.

Who Belle actually was

Belle Livingstone was a showgirl from Kansas, described in the newspapers of her day as having “poetic legs,” who spent the early twentieth century cavorting across Europe before returning to New York in 1927 at the age of 52 with excellent contacts and very little money. Prohibition was in full swing, and Belle, having been shown the city’s secret drinking clubs by the legendary hostess Texas Guinan, decided the correct response was to open her own.

Her first attempt, the One Man House on East 52nd Street, charged a $200 membership and went broke. Her second, the Silver Room on Park Avenue, was raided by federal agents. Arrested and accused of violating the Volstead Act, she offered one of the great deadpan defences in the history of licensing: she had merely, she said, done as any hostess did, and offered her guests a glass of champagne. The confiscated liquor, she maintained, belonged to the clients.

The Country Club, and the goldfish

Her third and finest venture was the Fifty-Eighth Street Country Club, in a five-storey house at 126 East 58th Street. Before opening it she reportedly asked the gangster and rival club-owner Owney Madden whether he minded; he told her to go as far as she liked. The club had Florentine ceilings, Italian marble floors, a brook stocked with live goldfish, and – four decades before the phrase “competitive socialising” was coined by a marketing department – an indoor miniature golf range. Champagne cost $40. When the place was finally raided in late 1930, Belle attempted to escape across the rooftops in a set of red pyjamas, and afterwards served a month in prison, entirely undaunted.

Belle Livingstone’s 58th Street Country Club on the map.

The verdict

The Peckham revival, staged by the immersive-storytelling company The Lost Estate, wraps this history in a six-course Park Avenue tasting menu – shrimp and crayfish cocktail, sirloin with lobster Bordelaise, New York cheesecake – and three sets from a house band called The 58th Street Stompers, all delivered across the better part of four hours amid Art Deco staging that leans hard into the golden age of American nightlife. The 4.8 rating across 934 reviews suggests the Jazz Age translates rather well to SE15, and that diners rather enjoy being talked at by a fictionalised Kansas showgirl between courses. Regular readers will note that Belle’s indoor mini-golf makes her the direct ancestor of every axe-throwing, shuffleboarding, crazy-golfing venue the Prat has catalogued from Clapham to Kensington; she simply had the decency to do it during an actual crime wave. A themed night out that turns out to be a genuine history lesson is a rare thing. This one keeps the goldfish metaphorical and the facts intact.

2 thoughts on “Belle Livingstone’s 58th Street Country Club, Peckham”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *