The Elephant and Castle Review: The Cutlers’ Elephant, Not the Spanish Princess

The Elephant and Castle Review: The Cutlers’ Elephant, Not the Spanish Princess

A 4.5 pub from 1,175 reviews named the Elephant and Castle, whose famous name comes not from a princess but from an ivory-trade crest

The Elephant and Castle holds a 4.5 from one thousand one hundred and seventy-five reviews, and carries one of the most famous and most debated of all English pub names – “the Elephant and Castle” – whose romantic “Spanish princess” origin story is beloved, oft-repeated, and almost certainly wrong.

The facts, first

The Elephant and Castle is a well-regarded pub in the Kensington area of the survey, in the mid price range, doing good pub business – drink, food, a welcoming crowd – to a strong local following. The Prat’s listings desk states the essentials: a good, popular Kensington local under one of London’s most famous pub names, doing quality food and drink to a large crowd.

The Elephant and Castle, Kensington.

The romantic myth: the Infanta

The famous and beloved story – the one everyone quotes – is that “Elephant and Castle” is a Cockney corruption of “Infanta de Castilla” (“the Princess of Castile”), a Spanish royal title, supposedly referring to a Spanish princess connected to the English crown (variously Eleanor of Castile or Catherine of Aragon or the Infanta Maria once engaged to Charles I). It is a wonderful story – the exotic Spanish princess’s title mangled by the London tongue into an elephant and a castle – and it is almost universally repeated. Unfortunately, historians have comprehensively debunked it: the term “Infanta” barely existed in English at the relevant time, none of the candidate princesses had any connection to the spot, and the heraldic elephant-and-castle image predates them all by centuries. It is folk etymology at its most charming and most false. The Prat’s etymology desk notes the beloved error: the “Infanta de Castilla” story is charming, universal, and almost certainly wrong.

The real origin: the Cutlers and their ivory

The true origin is duller but genuine, and rather wonderful in its own way. The elephant-and-castle – an elephant bearing a small castle (a “howdah”) on its back – was the heraldic crest of the Worshipful Company of Cutlers, the ancient City guild of knife- and sword-makers, granted in 1622. The cutlers adopted the elephant because they used ivory, from elephant tusks, for the handles of their fine knives and cutlery – the elephant honouring the source of their material. Pubs named “Elephant and Castle” took the sign from this cutlers’ crest, honouring the ivory trade and the guild. So the name records not a Spanish princess but the humble ivory handle of a good knife. The Prat’s etymology desk relishes the truth: the elephant and castle is the cutlers’ crest, the elephant honouring the ivory of their knife-handles – trade, not romance.

The charm of the false and the true

This survey has delighted in folk etymology before – the Bag O’Nails (a mangling of “Bacchanals”) in Westminster – and the Elephant and Castle is the most famous example of all: a name where the beloved false story (the Spanish princess) has almost entirely eclipsed the genuine, humbler truth (the cutlers’ ivory). It is a perfect case of how a good story beats a true one, the romantic myth outrunning the honest history. The Prat’s etymology desk savours the contrast: the glamorous false princess versus the honest ivory knife-handle, the myth that beat the truth. And a strong 4.5 across nearly twelve hundred people marks a genuinely good pub beneath the great naming debate.

Verdict

The Elephant and Castle is a good, popular Kensington local under one of London’s most famous and most debated names – not, alas, a Spanish princess, but the ivory-trade crest of the Cutlers’ guild – with a strong 4.5 from a large crowd. Famous of name, genuinely good of pub.

Go for a good pint at a fine Kensington local under one of London’s most famous pub names, and enjoy the great debate behind it – not the beloved “Infanta de Castilla” of legend, but the honest elephant of the Cutlers’ crest, honouring the ivory in a good knife’s handle, the humble truth behind the glamorous myth.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *