Smith and Wollensky Review: Two Names Picked Out of a Phone Book

Smith and Wollensky Review: Two Names Picked Out of a Phone Book

An American steakhouse whose founders chose the name at random, and then built an empire on it

Smith and Wollensky is an American steakhouse on the Strand, in the Adelphi, with two and a half thousand reviews, a 4.5, and a bill north of a hundred pounds a head.

Neither Smith nor Wollensky exists.

The phone book

The story – told by the founders themselves, repeated for decades, and now essentially canon – is that they opened in New York in 1977, needed a name, opened a telephone directory, and picked two at random. Smith. Wollensky.

That is it. That is the entire origin of the brand. Two surnames, selected by chance from a book of strangers, attached to a restaurant, and then built into an international steakhouse group with a Manhattan flagship and a London site in a Georgian district.

The Prat’s branding desk has spent eight batches now cataloguing the naming conventions of the London bar trade – the phantoms, the puns, the misspellings, the digits standing in for letters – and would like to formally record that Smith and Wollensky is the purest case yet encountered.

Theodore Bullfrog was named after nobody. Smith and Wollensky was named after two specific people who were never consulted, never compensated, and almost certainly never knew.

Smith and Wollensky. Neither of them has ever been in.

Somewhere, a Wollensky

There was, in New York in 1977, an actual Wollensky. A person, with a life, a job, a telephone number in a directory. And one day a restaurant opened bearing their surname and nobody rang to tell them.

The Prat has been unable to trace them. We tried. We would very much like to know whether they ever walked past a Smith and Wollensky, saw their own name over the door of an expensive steakhouse, and had to sit down.

The steak

Excellent, and it needs to be, at these prices. Dry-aged in-house, USDA prime, cooked hard and fast in the American style, which is a different thing from the British steakhouse and considerably better at what it is trying to do.

The room is what you expect: dark wood, white tablecloths, a wine list with a spine, and a clientele that is roughly seventy per cent expense account. The service is exceptional, because the service is what an expense account is actually buying.

The Adelphi, again

You are eating in the Adelphi – the Adam brothers’ great Georgian riverside development, most of which was demolished in 1936 to put up an office block, and which we have already mourned once in this series at Theodore Bullfrog.

What survives is fragments: a few streets, a few facades, the names. An American steakhouse named after two strangers from a New York phone book now occupies part of it.

The Prat’s preservation desk has no comment beyond noting that the building the Adams actually built would have been considerably more interesting than anything anybody has put on the site since, and that this is true of most of London.

Verdict

Superb steak, serious money, immaculate service, and a name lifted from a phone book by two men who could not think of anything better and were entirely right not to worry about it.

Go if it is an occasion. Order the ribeye. And spare a thought for the Wollenskys, who gave the world a steakhouse and got nothing.

2 thoughts on “Smith and Wollensky Review: Two Names Picked Out of a Phone Book”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *