Sager and Wilde Review: The Wine List Is the Whole Argument

Sager and Wilde Review: The Wine List Is the Whole Argument

A serious wine bar under a railway arch, and the by-the-glass list is the only thing in this survey that has ever mattered

Sager and Wilde holds a 4.4 from four hundred and ninety people, charges twenty to sixty pounds, and it is a serious wine bar.

And the thing it does, which almost nobody in London does properly, is the by-the-glass list.

The problem

An open bottle of wine is a race against oxygen.

The moment the cork comes out, the wine begins to change – and within a day or two, for most wines, it has gone from interesting to tired to actively unpleasant.

Which means a bar offering wine by the glass is taking a risk on every bottle it opens. If it does not sell that bottle within a day, it throws the remainder away.

And the consequence is the thing that has annoyed every wine drinker in Britain their entire life: the by-the-glass list is six wines long, and all six are the most robust, most commercial, least interesting things in the building – because those are the ones that will definitely sell.

You cannot put a serious bottle on a by-the-glass list. The arithmetic forbids it.

Sager and Wilde. The glass list is the argument. And it is a good one.

The two solutions

And we have found both across six postcodes.

Argon. Which we found at Vagabond, and which is an inert gas that sits on top of the wine in the bottle like a blanket and keeps the oxygen off – so that an open bottle holds for weeks rather than days, and a bar can have a hundred bottles open at once and lose nothing.

Or the shop-and-bar. You buy the whole bottle at retail and pay a small corkage to drink it there, so nothing is ever left open. Bedford Street Wines. Humble Grape. Planet of the Grapes. Vinoteca. And Vagabond, which does both.

The wine is identical. The saving is enormous. The only thing you have surrendered is the presumption that you are entitled to a chair.

What this one does

It simply takes the loss.

It opens interesting bottles, prices them properly, and accepts that some of them will not sell in time – and it does this because the people running it care more about the list than about the margin.

Which is not a business model. It is a position.

And it is the reason the list is what it is, and it is why the room has been taken seriously by people who take wine seriously for over a decade.

The arch

Which we wrote about at Mother Kelly’s: a railway arch is a brick tube with good acoustics, a stable temperature and no daylight, and every good one in east London is there because the ground floor was too expensive.

Every velvet rope in this city is a lease negotiation in fancy dress.

Verdict

Excellent. Go, and drink something by the glass that you would never have bought a bottle of.

That is the entire point and almost nowhere else in London will let you.

Natural wine, briefly

Because this district is full of it and almost nobody can define it.

There is no legal definition. That is the first and most important fact and it explains most of the argument.

Broadly it means: minimal intervention, no added yeasts, little or no added sulphur, nothing filtered out, nothing corrected.

Which produces wines that are sometimes extraordinary and sometimes actively faulty – and the honest position, which almost nobody in the movement will take, is that both of those things are true and that the second is not rare.

A good natural wine is a great wine. A bad one is vinegar, and it is being sold at fourteen pounds a glass, and somebody is telling you the funk is intentional.

One thought on “Sager and Wilde Review: The Wine List Is the Whole Argument”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *