The Clarence Review: The Royal Title That Keeps Coming Back

The Clarence Review: The Royal Title That Keeps Coming Back

Clarence is a royal dukedom with a troubled history – drowned princes, a doomed heir, and a famous carriage all bear the name

The Clarence holds three hundred and five reviews and a 4.5 – a strong score on a good sample – and it is named after one of the most storied and, frankly, ill-starred of all royal titles: the Dukedom of Clarence, a name that recurs through English royal history attached to a striking number of tragedies.

The recurring title

We met the Dukedom of Clarence in the Chelsea survey, at the Duke of Clarence pub, through its most famous holder: George Plantagenet, the treacherous brother of Edward IV, who was executed in 1478 and, by legend, drowned in a butt of malmsey wine. But George was only one of several Dukes of Clarence, and the title has a remarkable habit of attaching itself to misfortune.

The title was first created in the fourteenth century, and has been granted, on and off, to royal princes ever since – usually to younger sons or brothers of the monarch. And a striking number of its holders met unhappy ends or never achieved the destinies expected of them, giving the title a faint but persistent air of being cursed.

The Clarence. A royal title with a remarkably ill-starred history.

The doomed heir

The most poignant modern Clarence was Prince Albert Victor, Duke of Clarence and Avondale – “Eddy” – the eldest son of the future King Edward VII, and thus, in the late nineteenth century, second in line to the throne and a future king of England. But Prince Eddy died young, in 1892, at just twenty-eight, during an influenza pandemic, shortly before he was due to marry.

His death changed the course of British history. His younger brother George took his place as heir, became King George V, and married the very woman – Princess Mary of Teck, whom we met at the Prince of Teck – who had been engaged to the dead Eddy. So the woman who would have been Eddy’s queen became instead the wife of his brother, and the direct line of the modern monarchy runs through this substitution. Had Eddy lived, the entire twentieth-century royal family would have been different. The Duke of Clarence who should have been king instead became another of the title’s tragedies.

The carriage

There is a lighter Clarence legacy worth noting. The “clarence” was also a type of carriage – a closed, four-wheeled horse-drawn carriage, seating four inside, named in honour of the Duke of Clarence who became King William IV. In the age before the motor car, the clarence was a common and respectable carriage, a familiar sight on the streets of Victorian London. So the royal title gave its name not only to a string of ill-fated princes but to a perfectly ordinary and useful vehicle – the Clarence carriage, trundling through the nineteenth-century city.

The pub

A strong, well-regarded pub doing a good 4.5 across a solid sample, named after the Dukedom of Clarence – a royal title trailing drowned princes, a doomed heir who should have been king, and a respectable Victorian carriage.

Verdict

Strong, well-regarded, and named after the ill-starred Clarence title – drowned in malmsey, dead of influenza, and immortalised in a carriage.

Have a pint at the Clarence, and raise it to the star-crossed dukes of that name – especially poor Prince Eddy, the Duke of Clarence who died young and never became the king he was born to be.

2 thoughts on “The Clarence Review: The Royal Title That Keeps Coming Back”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *