Adam and Eve Review: The Fig Leaf Was Added by a Pope

Adam and Eve Review: The Fig Leaf Was Added by a Pope

The nudity in Renaissance art was painted over centuries later, and the man who did it was nicknamed the trouser-maker

The Adam and Eve holds a 4.1 from twelve hundred and fourteen people, charges ten to twenty pounds, and it is the second Adam and Eve in this survey.

And this time we are going to talk about the fig leaf.

It is in the text

Which is the one thing that is.

Because Genesis does not say apple – it says fruit, and no species is named, and the apple is very probably a Latin pun, because malum means both evil and apple.

But the fig leaves are there, explicitly, in the next verse. They sewed them together and made themselves coverings.

Which is, incidentally, decent evidence that the fruit was a fig, since it is the tree that is actually mentioned.

Adam and Eve. The fig leaves are in the text. The ones on the statues are not.

And then they went on everything

Which is the part that is not in the text at all.

Because an enormous quantity of classical and Renaissance art depicts the nude – and it was not considered scandalous at the time it was made.

And centuries later, it was covered up.

The Fig Leaf Campaign

Which is a real thing, and it happened across Europe.

Fig leaves were carved, cast, and plastered onto existing statues – frequently by chipping off what was there first, which is irreversible.

And paintings were overpainted.

And the Sistine Chapel

Which is the great example.

Because Michelangelo’s Last Judgment was full of nudes – and it caused an argument almost immediately, and after his death the Council of Trent hardened the position.

And a painter was employed to add drapery.

His name was Daniele da Volterra.

And he was nicknamed, for the rest of history, Il Braghettone – the breeches-maker. The trouser-maker.

He was a serious artist. That is what he is remembered for.

Which is the finding

Eight postcodes and twelve hundred and thirty-five articles.

The tellable version wins – and a man who did competent work for decades is remembered entirely for painting trousers onto somebody else’s masterpiece because he was told to.

And some of it has been removed, in restoration – and some has been left, because the overpainting is now itself four hundred years old and part of the history.

Which is a Ship of Theseus, and nobody has an answer.

And the Vatican has a box of them

Which is the ending, and it is genuinely true.

Because when the fig leaves were removed from statues in later restorations, they had to go somewhere.

And there is a persistent and well-attested account of a collection of plaster fig leaves held in the Vatican – kept, catalogued, and no longer attached to anything.

A drawer full of censorship, removed from the objects it was censoring, preserved as an artefact in its own right.

The Prat’s editorial desk finds this entirely delightful.

Because it is the constraint outliving the thing it constrained – a box of plaster modesty, in a drawer, in Rome, describing an anxiety that nobody now has, filed and numbered.

Verdict

Good pub, cheap, honest number.

One thought on “Adam and Eve Review: The Fig Leaf Was Added by a Pope”

  1. British people will never say “I’m tired”; they’ll say “I could do with a nap” and then proceed to stay awake for another six hours out of sheer stubbornness.

Leave a Reply