Miraflores Review: The Pisco Sour Is a War That Never Ended

Miraflores Review: The Pisco Sour Is a War That Never Ended

Peru and Chile have been arguing about who owns pisco for a century, and both governments have taken formal positions

Miraflores holds a 4.6 from four hundred and five people, charges twenty to sixty pounds, and it is Peruvian.

And the drink it is famous for is the subject of an actual diplomatic dispute.

The pisco war

Peru and Chile both make pisco. Both claim it. And both have made it a matter of state.

This is not a bar argument. There are trade regulations, appellation claims, government-funded promotional campaigns and international legal filings.

Peru has a protected designation of origin. Chile has its own. Each has, at various points, refused to allow the other’s product to be sold under the name in its territory.

Miraflores. Peru and Chile have been arguing about pisco for a century.

The Peruvian case

There is a town called Pisco. It is in Peru. It has been there for centuries and it is where the spirit was shipped from.

Peruvian pisco is distilled from specific permitted grape varieties, to a single distillation, with no water added afterwards – which means it comes off the still at drinking strength and cannot be adjusted.

Which is a genuinely demanding rule. You have one chance to get the strength right.

The Chilean case

Chile has a region it has named Pisco – and it renamed a town Pisco Elqui in 1936, which the Peruvians regard as the single most brazen act in the entire dispute.

Chilean pisco permits more varieties, allows the addition of water, and is made in far larger quantity.

It is, by volume, the dominant product. It is also the one that most of the world drinks without knowing there is an argument.

The Prat’s position

We are not going to have one, and we are going to say why.

Eight postcodes and eight hundred and twelve articles have taught us that origin claims of this kind are almost never settled by evidence.

They are settled by who tells the story better and who has the trade lawyers.

The town is in Peru. The volume is in Chile. Both of those are facts and neither of them ends it.

The egg white

Which is the thing in the drink and which is doing real work.

It is not for flavour. Egg white tastes of essentially nothing.

It is a foaming agent and an emulsifier – the proteins denature when you shake them, trapping air, and they produce a dense stable foam that sits on top and completely changes the texture.

And it softens the acid. A sour without egg white is sharper and thinner and arrives faster.

Shake it hard, without ice, first. That is the whole technique.

Verdict

Excellent food, strong number.

Order the pisco sour, and do not ask which country it is from.

Peru, briefly

Which has one of the great cuisines and which Britain discovered about ten years ago.

It is a genuine fusion, and it happened over centuries rather than on a menu.

Indigenous Andean ingredients – potatoes, of which Peru has thousands of varieties, and chillies, and quinoa – met Spanish technique, then West African cooking, then a very large Japanese immigration in the late nineteenth century, then Chinese.

Which is why ceviche is raw fish cured in citrus, and why there is a whole category called chifa that is Chinese-Peruvian, and why nikkei is Japanese-Peruvian.

None of it was designed. All of it was people cooking with what was there.

One thought on “Miraflores Review: The Pisco Sour Is a War That Never Ended”

  1. Someone thinking they should move somewhere with competent governance. You won’t because it doesn’t exist and that’s the horror.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *