St Paul’s has three domes. The one you see from outside is not the one you see from inside, and neither is holding anything up.
Madison sits on the roof of One New Change with thirteen thousand two hundred and seventy-nine reviews and a 4.5, which makes it the most-reviewed venue in this entire four-postcode survey.
And it is there for one reason: it is close enough to St Paul’s to feel that you could touch it.
The dome is three domes
This is the thing nobody knows and it is Wren’s greatest trick.
The dome you see from the street – the huge, elegant, lead-covered one that defines the skyline – is not a structural dome. It is a shell. It is an outer skin, built for the view from outside, and it is holding up nothing but itself.
The dome you see from inside, standing in the crossing and looking up at the paintings, is a completely different dome. It is much shallower and much lower, because a dome that looks right from inside is the wrong shape to look right from outside, and Wren refused to compromise either.
And between them, invisible from anywhere, is a third – a brick cone, structural, hidden, doing all the actual work. It carries the weight of the lantern, the ball and the cross above it, and it is the reason the whole thing has not fallen down.
Why he did it
Because the two audiences want incompatible things.
A dome that is tall and dramatic on the skyline is, from directly underneath, a distant and gloomy tunnel. A dome that is beautifully proportioned from the floor is, from a mile away, a squat bump.
Wren wanted both. So he built both, and put a load-bearing cone between them where nobody would ever see it.
The Prat’s architectural desk regards this as the single most audacious act of deliberate deception in British building, and notes that it has been admired by hundreds of millions of people who believe they are looking at a dome and are in fact looking at a hat.
The cathedral he wanted
Was not the one he built.
Wren’s preferred design – the Great Model, which still exists and which you can go and look at – was a radical Greek cross, domed, centralised, and startlingly modern.
The clergy hated it. They wanted a long nave, in the traditional English form, because that is what a cathedral was for and what processions require.
He was reportedly reduced to tears by the rejection. He then produced a compromise, got royal permission to alter it as he went, and proceeded to alter it enormously – which is how the building ended up with the dome he wanted on the plan they insisted on.
He was seventy-six when it was finished. He had been working on it for thirty-five years.
The bar
Twenty to sixty pounds, and it is the sixth rooftop in this survey – and it holds a 4.5, which breaks our pattern.
Every other rooftop across four postcodes has landed at 4.1 or below unless it had walls. Madison has the view to beat the weather, and thirteen thousand people agree.
Verdict
Go for the view. It is the best in London and there is no argument.
And look at the dome, and know that it is a shell, and that the real one is a brick cone hiding inside it doing all the work.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

The layer of specific knowledge here could only come from reading too many government documents or attending too many meetings. Both indicate distress.
The thing about good writing is you can feel how much thought went into every sentence. This is that.