Boisdale Review: The Tartan Was Very Largely Invented for a Royal Visit

Boisdale Review: The Tartan Was Very Largely Invented for a Royal Visit

Clan tartans as we know them are a nineteenth-century construction, and a great many were made up by weavers

Boisdale of Canary Wharf holds a 4.2 from two thousand five hundred and twenty-six people, charges over a hundred pounds a head, and it is Scottish, and there is a great deal of tartan.

Which was very largely invented.

The ban

After the Jacobite rising of 1745, the government set out to destroy the Highland clan system – deliberately, systematically, and with considerable success.

The Dress Act banned Highland dress. The clan chiefs’ judicial powers were abolished. The language was suppressed. People were cleared off the land.

And the ban stood for about thirty-five years.

Boisdale. The clan tartans were very largely invented in the nineteenth century.

And by the time it was lifted, the knowledge was gone

Which is the crucial fact.

Because a generation had grown up not wearing it, and the weavers who had made the old patterns were dead or dispersed, and the district traditions – such as they were – had broken.

And the honest historical position is that pre-ban tartan was very substantially a matter of region and weaver rather than a strict system of clan identification.

You wore what was woven locally, in the dyes available locally.

And then George IV came to Edinburgh

In 1822.

And the visit was stage-managed by Walter Scott – who was a novelist, and who was extremely good at this, and who essentially designed a pageant.

Chiefs were asked to appear in their clan tartan.

And a great many of them did not have one.

So they got one. From the weavers. Who were delighted to supply, and who assigned patterns, and who wrote them down, and who thereby created a system that everybody has believed in ever since.

And the King himself appeared in tartan, with flesh-coloured tights.

Which is the finding

Eight postcodes and a thousand and one hundred and sixty-nine articles.

A tradition invented in 1822 is still a tradition. It just is not the one it says it is.

The Green Man was named in 1939 by one woman in one article. The Tudor rose was designed by a king with a bad claim. Art Deco was named in the 1960s. The Pilgrim Fathers were called that by nineteenth-century Americans.

And the tartan is real, and it is worn sincerely, and it means something to people – and it is younger than the steam engine.

Verdict

And Scott did the same to the Highlands

Which is the bigger crime, and it is worth stating.

Because the romantic Highlands – the noble clansman, the mist, the tragic Jacobite, the wild beautiful emptiness – is very substantially Walter Scott’s invention, and it sold enormously.

And the emptiness was not romantic. It was recent, and it was deliberate.

The Clearances removed people from that land – evicted, burned out, put on ships – to make room for sheep, which were more profitable.

So a landscape was emptied of its people, and then sold back to the world as sublime and lonely, by a novelist, within a generation.

Verdict

Excellent, extremely expensive, honest number.

2 thoughts on “Boisdale Review: The Tartan Was Very Largely Invented for a Royal Visit”

  1. Someone thinking they should move to the countryside for better governance. You won’t because it’s identical everywhere which is somehow worse.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *