Old Spot Review: One Review, and the Gloucestershire Old Spot Is a Real Pig

Old Spot Review: One Review, and the Gloucestershire Old Spot Is a Real Pig

An orchard pig, said to be bruised by falling apples, and it very nearly went extinct

Old Spot Pub Co. holds a 3.0 from one review.

One.

Which is not a rating. It is one person, one evening, one mood – and it is displayed to the entire internet in the same font, on the same scale, as a 4.8 from fifteen thousand.

The pig

Because the Gloucestershire Old Spot is a real breed, and it is one of the oldest pedigree pig breeds in the world.

Large. White. Black spots. Enormous drooping ears that fall over its eyes.

The Old Spot. An orchard pig. And it nearly went extinct.

The orchard pig

Which is the traditional name, and it describes what it was for.

Because it was kept in orchards, and in cider country – and it lived on the windfall apples, and the whey from the dairy, and whatever it could root up.

It was a waste converter.

A pig that turned the things nobody else wanted into meat, on ground that was already being used for something else.

And the folk story is that the spots are bruises – from apples falling on its back.

Which is charming, and which is obviously nonsense, and the farmers who tell it know perfectly well that it is nonsense.

And it nearly died out

Which is the serious part.

Because a slow-growing, fatty, outdoor pig is commercially hopeless against a fast-growing lean one raised indoors.

And the twentieth century wanted lean pork, cheap, fast – and the Old Spot could not compete, and the numbers collapsed.

It came genuinely close to extinction.

And it survived because of the Rare Breeds Survival Trust, and because a small number of people would not let it go.

Which is the finding

Eight postcodes and twelve hundred and twenty-five articles.

The thing that survived because nobody could be bothered to improve it turns out to be the thing worth having.

Italy kept three hundred and fifty grape varieties because it was never a country. The Andes kept four thousand potatoes because nobody arrived to say which was best.

And Europe took four potatoes, as clones, and a fungus took the lot.

The Suffolk Punch is now rarer than the giant panda.

And the pig is back

Which is the good news, and it is a small one.

Because the Old Spot now has protected status in Europe – a designation of origin, like champagne, or parmesan – and it can only be called that if it is the real thing.

And it turns out that a slow-growing, fatty, outdoor pig produces considerably better meat than a fast lean one, and people will pay for it.

The market destroyed it. And then the market saved it.

The right thing frequently gets done for the wrong reason, and it counts anyway.

And one review is one person

Which is worth saying plainly, because it is the last time we will say it in this district.

A 3.0 from one person is not a bad pub. It is one bad evening, possibly not even the pub’s fault, permanently attached to a business that has no other evidence to set against it.

The next person through the door moves this number by up to two whole stars, on their own.

Verdict

One review. Not a rating.

Go, be the second, and double the evidence.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *