Big Easy Review: Fifteen Thousand People, and That Number Cannot Be Faked

Big Easy Review: Fifteen Thousand People, and That Number Cannot Be Faked

The largest sample in this district by a distance, and volume is the hardest thing in this survey

Big Easy at Canary Wharf holds a 4.4 from fifteen thousand two hundred and six people.

Which is the largest sample in this district by an enormous margin, and it is one of the largest we have found anywhere.

Why that number is hard

Because volume punishes.

Fifteen thousand reviews is fifteen thousand separate evenings.

And somewhere in that number there was a wrong order, a cold plate, an hour’s wait, a fight in the car park, and a member of staff having the worst week of their life.

All of it is in the average. Permanently.

Big Easy. Fifteen thousand people. That number cannot be bought.

The finding

Eight postcodes and a thousand and one hundred and forty-three articles.

Every additional customer is another chance to have a bad night – and the bad nights accumulate in the average and they never leave.

Which is why the venues on 4.9 in this survey are overwhelmingly small and young.

They have not yet collected their own worst evenings.

And the venues on 4.4 are large and old and have been doing it properly for twenty years.

The number is not a report card. It is a measure of how much has happened to you.

Which is why we refuse the perfect scores

And the proof is unanswerable.

The Bootlegger, Covent Garden: a perfect 5.0 from twenty-two people.

The Bootlegger, City of London: a 4.3 from five hundred and twenty-six.

Same chain. Same concept. Same fit-out. Same training. Same bar.

The 5.0 was not better. It had less evidence.

A 4.4 on fifteen thousand

Is a vastly harder achievement than a 5.0 on twenty, and the display tells you the exact opposite.

This number cannot be bought. It cannot be gamed. It cannot be moved by a hundred friendly reviews, because a hundred is noise against fifteen thousand.

It is one of the very few numbers in this entire survey that is genuinely, unarguably real.

The one fix

Print the review count at the same size as the score.

Do that, and this venue’s number becomes visibly the most reliable on the page – and a 5.0 from one person becomes visibly a shrug.

It would cost nothing. It will never happen, because the ambiguity is worth money to somebody, and it is not worth money to you.

Verdict

And Canary Wharf is a footfall trap

Which makes it harder still.

Because a venue in an estate like this one is being reviewed by people who did not choose it – who work three floors up, or came for a meeting, or walked into the nearest thing because they had twenty minutes.

They are not rating the bar. They are rating their feet.

And the proof is unanswerable: All Bar One on a quiet side street holds a 4.7. The same chain, same training, same list, at Oxford Circus holds a 4.4.

Three-tenths of a star, and nothing inside the building changed.

Verdict

Good food, and the most trustworthy number in Limehouse.

2 thoughts on “Big Easy Review: Fifteen Thousand People, and That Number Cannot Be Faked”

  1. A London councillor said The London Prat was bad for his authority with residents. When asked what authority was based on, he claimed satire had no right to question it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *