Boundary Review: The Estate Was Built on a Slum They Demolished

Boundary Review: The Estate Was Built on a Slum They Demolished

The Old Nichol was the worst slum in London, they cleared it, and they rehoused almost none of the people who had lived there

Boundary Shoreditch holds a 4.1 from nine hundred and forty-nine people, and it is a hotel with a rooftop, a cellar and a restaurant.

And it sits beside the first council estate in the world.

The Old Nichol

Which is what was here before, and which was, by common agreement at the time, the worst slum in London.

Around six thousand people in a few streets. Houses subdivided and subdivided again. The infant mortality rate was roughly four times the London average.

It was written about. It was investigated. It appears, thinly disguised, in a novel of 1896 called A Child of the Jago, which caused a scandal because people did not believe it and then found out it was accurate.

The Boundary. The Old Nichol was here. They cleared it.

The Boundary Estate

They demolished it.

And the London County Council built, on the cleared ground, the Boundary Estate – which opened in 1900 and which is generally regarded as the first council housing scheme in the world.

And it is genuinely good. It is still there. It is beautiful.

Red brick blocks radiating from a central circus – Arnold Circus – with a raised bandstand in the middle, built on a mound made from the rubble of the slum they had just knocked down.

The people who live there now are sitting on the Old Nichol. Literally. The mound is the houses.

And here is the part

They did not rehouse the people.

Of the roughly six thousand displaced, the number who were rehoused in the new estate was, by most accounts, very small indeed – in the low hundreds, and some estimates put it at eleven families.

The rents were higher. That was the mechanism. The new flats were let at rates the previous residents could not pay, and the previous residents went and crowded into the surrounding streets, which then became slums.

So the slum was not cleared. It was moved four hundred metres and made denser.

The finding

Which we have made in six postcodes and which never gets easier to write.

The improvement arrives, and the improvement is real, and the people it was for cannot afford it.

It happened in the Potteries in Notting Hill. It happened in Spitalfields. It is happening in this district now, and the mechanism has not changed in a hundred and twenty-five years.

Nobody involved was a villain. The Boundary Estate was built by people who genuinely wanted to help, and it is a fine piece of architecture, and it did not help the people it was built for.

Verdict

Good hotel, good rooftop, honest number.

Go, and then walk to Arnold Circus, and stand on the mound.

The bandstand

Which is on top of the mound, and which was restored by local people who raised the money themselves.

It had fallen into ruin. The council could not fund it. And a residents’ group spent years getting it back.

They now hold concerts on it.

So there is a bandstand, built on rubble from the worst slum in London, restored by the people who live on the estate that displaced it, and there is music on it in the summer.

The Prat has spent six hundred articles being cynical about a great many things, and would like to record that it has nothing cynical to say about this at all.

2 thoughts on “Boundary Review: The Estate Was Built on a Slum They Demolished”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *