A cheap late-opening sports bar in the busiest drinking street in east London is being punished for every single thing it does right
The Cornershop Bar holds a 3.7 from eight hundred and twenty-seven people, charges ten to forty pounds, and it is one of the lower-rated venues in this district.
And we are going to defend it, because we have defended this exact number in five other postcodes and the argument does not change.
What the venue is
Cheap. Open late. Large. Shows sport. Has a dance floor. Lets everybody in.
Every single one of those is a rating penalty and we have documented all of them.
The penalties
Cheap is punished. A cheap venue draws from the whole public rather than a filtered slice – which means it gets everybody, including everybody having a bad day and everybody who would have complained wherever they went.
The Wetherspoon in Shepherd’s Bush: 3.9. The Central Bar: 3.9. The Queens Tavern: 3.9. Freedom in Soho: 3.7 from twelve hundred people.
Every one of them is genuinely useful and every one is rated below a cocktail bar that has served twenty-two people.
Late is punished, and it is punished hardest. A venue that people leave at three in the morning is reviewed the following day, by somebody who feels terrible, and who is attributing their condition to the last building they were in.
The Steel Yard in the City sits on a 3.9 for exactly this reason.
Volume is punished. Eight hundred reviews is eight hundred chances to have had a bad night, and every one of them is in the average permanently.
And the street
Which is the thing that finishes it.
This bar is on the busiest drinking street in east London on a Saturday night. It is not the first venue of anybody’s evening. It is the fourth or the fifth.
And the star rating measures the gap between what somebody expected and what they got – and a person arriving at midnight having already been to four places is not in a state to assess anything at all.
What the number is not measuring
Whether the room is any good. It has never measured that. Not once in five hundred and sixty-four articles.
It measures the price, the hour, the pavement, and how many people have already been through the door.
The Cornershop is cheap, late, large and open. It is being marked down for being available.
The mirror
MAP Maison, in this district, holds a 4.8 – and it is small, expensive, and closes early.
Both of those numbers are correct. Neither of them is about the drinks.
Verdict
Go and make your own mind up, and do not let a number decide it for you.
Eight hundred people are not wrong. They are answering a different question from the one you are asking.
What we would fix
Print the review count at the same size as the score.
And while we are asking: show the price band, the capacity, and the closing time.
Because a 3.7 from a cheap late-night bar with a dance floor and no door policy, and a 4.8 from a twenty-seat cocktail bar that closes at eleven, are not comparable numbers – and every listing site on earth displays them side by side as though they were.
It would cost nothing. It will never happen. The ambiguity is worth money to somebody, and it is not worth money to you.
I am a Lagos-born poet and satirical journalist navigating West London’s contradictions. I survived lions at six, taught English by Irish nuns, now wielding words as weapons against absurdity. Illegal in London but undeniable. I write often for https://bohiney.com/author/junglepussy/.
As a young child, I was mostly influenced by the television show Moesha, starring singer and actress Brandy. Growing up, I would see Brandy on Moesha and see her keeping in her cornrows and her braids, but still flourish in her art and music, looking fly. I loved Moesha as a child, but now I take away something more special from it. Just because you’re a black girl, it doesn’t mean you need to only care about hair and makeup. Brandy cared about books, culture and where she was going — you can do both.
