Cocktail Club Old Street Review: The Fourth One, and the Rule Holds

Cocktail Club Old Street Review: The Fourth One, and the Rule Holds

4.7, 4.6, 4.5, 4.4 – and the branch with the fewest reviews wins, every single time, in every chain, in every district

The Cocktail Club near Old Street holds a 4.6 from fourteen hundred and fifteen people.

It is the fourth in this survey, and there is a fifth in this same district, and the set now reads: 4.7, 4.6, 4.5, 4.4.

The rule

The branch with the smallest sample wins.

Mansion House, in the City: 4.7 from three hundred and ninety-two people. The best score, the smallest sample.

Old Street: 4.6 from fourteen hundred and fifteen.

Monument: 4.5 from fifteen hundred and fifty-nine.

Oxford Circus: 4.4 from thirteen hundred and seven.

It has won every single time, in every chain, across six postcodes and five hundred and forty-five articles, and it has never once failed.

The Cocktail Club. Fewer witnesses. Better number. Every time.

Why volume punishes

Because it punishes mechanically and there is no defence.

Fifteen hundred reviews means fifteen hundred separate evenings – and somewhere in that number there was a bad Saturday, a broken cistern, a night the ice machine failed, and a member of staff having the worst week of their life.

All of it is in the average, permanently, and it cannot be removed.

Three hundred and ninety reviews has absorbed a fraction of that. It has not been open long enough, or busy enough, to accumulate its own worst nights.

The proof

Two Bootleggers, same chain, same concept.

The Covent Garden one holds a perfect 5.0 – from twenty-two people.

The City one holds a 4.3 – from five hundred and twenty-six.

Same bar. The 5.0 is not better. It is the same bar with less evidence.

We said so in the very first batch of this survey, before we had any of this data – we said a perfect record with twenty-two witnesses is a rumour and not a rating, and that you should go before the arithmetic catches up.

The arithmetic caught up, in the same chain, and it landed at 4.3.

What this means for you

Do not compare two scores without comparing their samples.

A 4.7 from three hundred and ninety and a 4.5 from fifteen hundred are not two different qualities of bar. They are two different quantities of information about the same bar.

And every listing site on earth shows you both, in the same font, on the same scale, with the review count underneath in grey, smaller.

Print the review count at the same size as the score. It would cost nothing. It will never happen.

Verdict

Good bar, cheap, loud, and honest about it.

You will not taste two-tenths of a star. Nobody can.

What a new venue should know

You will never score as well as you do in your first year.

Not because you get worse – you will almost certainly get better – but because the number will fall, and it will keep falling, and there is nothing you can do about it.

Every additional customer is another chance to have a bad night, and the bad nights accumulate in the average and never leave.

The venues on 4.9 in this survey are, overwhelmingly, small and young. The venues on 4.4 are large and old and have been doing it properly for twenty years.

The number is not a report card. It is a measure of how much has happened to you.

One thought on “Cocktail Club Old Street Review: The Fourth One, and the Rule Holds”

  1. Someone’s going to use LONDON PRAT in a London council objection and it’ll be rejected because it’s too accurate about how London actually works.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *