Queens Tavern Review: A 3.9, and Why That Is Not the Insult It Looks

Queens Tavern Review: A 3.9, and Why That Is Not the Insult It Looks

One hundred and fifty-one people, a below-average score, and a pub that has done nothing wrong

The Queens Tavern holds a 3.9 from a hundred and fifty-one people, which places it near the bottom of the Notting Hill file.

We are going to spend this article explaining why that number is very probably not telling you what you think it is telling you.

What a 3.9 actually is

It is not a disaster. Disasters do not survive – they hit a 2.1 and they close and the unit becomes a Tesco Express.

A 3.9 across a hundred and fifty people is the score of a pub where most people had a perfectly reasonable time and a meaningful minority left mildly annoyed about something specific.

And having now read a very large number of these reviews across two surveys, we can tell you what that something almost always is, and it is never the beer.

The three killers

The wait. Somebody stood at the bar for four minutes and was not looked at, and four minutes at a bar feels like eleven.

The temperature. British pubs are either arctic or tropical and there is no mechanism by which a customer can raise this.

And the toilets. It is always the toilets. The Prat has now read something in the region of two thousand pub reviews across two postcodes and can state with total confidence that the single largest destroyer of star ratings in this country is a lavatory that somebody found unsatisfactory at ten past nine on a Saturday.

Nobody writes a five-star review of a clean toilet. Everybody writes a two-star review of a bad one. The asymmetry is total and it is not recoverable.

The Queens Tavern. It is probably the toilets. It is always the toilets.

The unfairness of the aggregate

We have made this argument since the very first batch in Covent Garden and it holds here.

The star rating is not a measurement of quality. It is a measurement of the distance between what somebody expected and what they got – and it is dragged down disproportionately by cheap venues, busy venues, and venues that let everybody in.

The Wetherspoon in Shepherd’s Bush has a 3.9. It is the most genuinely useful building in this entire survey.

The Queens Tavern has a 3.9. It is a ten-to-twenty-pound local in a district where the median venue charges three times that.

The pub

A local. Plain, cheap, functional. The reviews mention the staff favourably, which we have established across two hundred and seventy-nine articles is the only indicator that reliably correlates with anything.

Verdict

Go and make your own mind up, and do not let a number decide it for you.

A hundred and fifty-one people are not wrong. They are simply answering a different question from the one you are asking.

The question they are actually answering

Not: is this a good pub.

But: did my evening go the way I hoped it would.

And those are completely different questions, and the second one is contaminated by the weather, the trains, the person they came with, the day they have had, and whether the toilets were acceptable at ten past nine on a Saturday.

Every rating in both of these surveys is an average of several hundred evenings, and the pub was only ever responsible for part of any of them.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *