Two minutes from Britain’s most decorated real ale pub sits a large, cheap, cheerful alternative, defined forever by proximity
The Chandos sits on St Martin’s Lane, a short walk from Trafalgar Square, and it has committed no crime. It is a large Samuel Smith’s pub with a big upstairs room, worn leather, and beer at prices that make grown Londoners emotional. Three thousand seven hundred people have reviewed it. It holds a respectable 4.2.
And it will never, ever escape the Harp.
The sentence
Somewhere in the archive of London pub writing there is a line – you will find versions of it on Londonist, in guidebooks, in the mouths of men in CAMRA fleeces – to the effect that the frugal or impoverished may prefer the cheaper, and much poorer, beer at the nearby Chandos.
Cheaper. And much poorer. It is a devastating construction, and it has followed the Chandos for years, and it is not even about the Chandos. It is about the Harp. The Chandos is the control group. It exists, in the literature, purely to make another pub look good.
In defence of being the second-best pub within 200 metres
Here is what the Chandos actually offers, unencumbered by comparison. It has seats. Actual seats, in numbers, upstairs in the Opera Room, which is more than can be said for the Harp on any evening ending in a Y, where the seating strategy is “arrive at 4pm or stand in a corridor for three hours.”
It is a Samuel Smith’s house, which means the beer is brewed in Tadcaster, costs a fraction of what the pub next door charges, and comes with the house rule set: no music, no phones on the table in some branches, no swearing, and an ambient sense that the landlord is disappointed in you. The pints are honest. The pints are cheap. The pints are, yes, poorer.
The Institute for Comparative Drinking in Walthamstow has quantified the trade-off: a pint at the Chandos is approximately 62 per cent as good as a pint at the Harp and approximately 44 per cent of the price, at which point you are, mathematically, winning, and everyone knows it, and nobody will say it out loud.
The theatre crowd
Its real function is pre-show. The Coliseum is next door. The Chandos absorbs an entire opera audience at 6:40pm, feeds them, waters them, and releases them at 7:25 in an orderly fashion, and then goes quiet, and then does it again at the interval. No other pub in London performs a public service this precise on this schedule and receives this little credit for it.
Watch the upstairs at 7:24. It empties like a bath. One minute there are ninety people and a low roar; the next there is a room full of glasses, a lone barman, and the specific silence of a place that has just done its job and been abandoned for it.
The Samuel Smith’s experience, for the uninitiated
You will not recognise a single brand behind the bar. This is deliberate. Samuel Smith’s brews everything itself, sells nothing else, and the resulting range has the air of a parallel universe in which Guinness, Peroni and Aperol were never invented and nobody has noticed.
The lager is fine. The stout is better than it has any right to be. The Old Brewery Bitter is a genuine article that costs less than a coffee in the piazza three minutes away, and the fact that this sentence is true tells you more about Covent Garden than about beer.
Verdict
Go to the Harp for the beer. Go to the Chandos because you would like to sit down, spend eleven pounds instead of twenty-six, and not be pressed against a stranger’s spine. Both are correct. Only one of them will ever be written up as a treasure, and it is not this one, and the Chandos has made its peace.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]
