Walrus and the Carpenter Review: They Eat All the Oysters

Walrus and the Carpenter Review: They Eat All the Oysters

Lewis Carroll wrote a poem in which two characters weep with sympathy for the creatures they are in the process of eating

The Walrus and the Carpenter holds a 4.4 from eighteen hundred and sixty-two people, charges twenty to thirty pounds, and is named after a poem that is considerably darker than anybody remembers.

What happens in it

A walrus and a carpenter are walking on a beach. They persuade a number of young oysters to come out for a walk with them.

The oysters come. They are eager. They are described as young, and as having their shoes on and their faces washed, and the eldest oyster – who knows better – stays behind and does not come.

And the walrus and the carpenter walk them along the beach, and then sit down on a rock, and eat every single one of them.

And while eating them, the walrus weeps. He says he deeply sympathises. He holds his handkerchief to his eyes, and he sorts out the largest oysters, and he cries as he eats.

The Walrus and the Carpenter. He wept. He ate them anyway.

The joke

Alice, having heard it, tries to decide which of the two she prefers.

She likes the Walrus best, because he was at least sorry for the oysters. Tweedledee points out that he ate more than the Carpenter, and was holding his handkerchief up so that the Carpenter could not count.

So she says she likes the Carpenter better – because he ate fewer.

And Tweedledum tells her he ate as many as he could get.

There is no right answer. That is the entire point. One of them is a hypocrite and the other is honest, and the oysters are equally dead either way, and Carroll leaves a small girl to work out which is worse.

The Prat’s literary desk regards it as the most efficiently cynical thing in Victorian children’s literature and notes that it is routinely read to five-year-olds as a bit of nonsense about a walrus.

What it is about

Nobody knows and Carroll never said.

It has been read as a satire on politicians, on imperialism, on religion, and on capital. There is a persistent theory that the Walrus and the Carpenter represent the Buddha and Jesus, which Carroll would have found astonishing and which will not go away.

The likeliest answer is the one nobody wants: that it is a poem about the fact that people will consume a thing while performing regret about it, and that the performance changes nothing whatsoever.

The oysters

Which we have already written about, at the Cow in Notting Hill – the food of the poor, so common that Dickens made a joke of it, until the beds collapsed and scarcity turned it into a luxury.

Every oyster you eat is an inversion. The walrus was eating a working man’s lunch.

Verdict

Good pub, superb name, and a poem in which two characters cry while eating children.

Go, order a pint, and reread it. It is four minutes long and it is not what you think.

Carroll, and the thing everybody wants to ask

We are going to address it once, briefly, because it hangs over every mention of him.

Charles Dodgson was a mathematics don at Christ Church, a pioneering photographer, and a man whose relationship with the Liddell children – and with Alice in particular – has been the subject of a hundred and fifty years of speculation, much of it lurid and almost all of it built on gaps in the record.

The honest position is that we do not know. Pages were cut from his diaries by his family after his death and nobody knows what was on them.

The Prat has spent four hundred articles refusing to fill gaps with the most tellable story available, and we are not going to start now.

One thought on “Walrus and the Carpenter Review: They Eat All the Oysters”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *