Permission Lounge Review: A Five-Star Rating That Actually Counts

Permission Lounge Review: A Five-Star Rating That Actually Counts

Ninety-four people. Five point zero. After eighty articles of complaining about sample sizes, we have to eat this one.

We have spent this entire series making one argument, over and over, with increasing irritation: a five-star rating means nothing without a sample size.

Nellie’s Tavern: 5.0 from one review. Upper Gods: 5.0 from three. Festival Bar: 5.0 from one. The Bootlegger: 5.0 from twenty-two. Bar at Restaurant 1890: 5.0 from six.

All of them meaningless. All of them presented, by every listing site on earth, above the Harp, which is the best pub in Britain and sits on a 4.6 from three and a half thousand people.

And then there is Permission Lounge.

Ninety-four

Ninety-four people have reviewed Permission Lounge. Every single one of them gave it five stars.

Not an average of 4.9. Not 4.95 rounded up. Five point zero, from ninety-four separate human beings, not one of whom found a single thing to complain about.

The Prat’s statistics desk has run this against the full survey and reports the following: at n=94, a perfect score has a probability, given the distribution of every other London bar in this dataset, that it describes as “not usefully distinguishable from zero.”

It should not exist. It exists.

Permission Lounge. Ninety-four for ninety-four. We have no explanation.

What could produce this

We have considered the options honestly.

It could be genuine. It is possible – not likely, but possible – that a small, high-touch venue with a limited number of covers and exceptional staff simply does not have bad nights, because it never has enough people in to have one.

It could be selection. If the room is small, expensive, and requires a degree of effort to reach, then everybody who gets in has already self-selected for wanting to be there, and we established at Barrafina that a customer who worked to arrive is worth roughly 0.4 stars before the first drink is poured.

Or the ninety-four are not a random sample of the public. They are a sample of the people who liked it enough to bother, and everybody who was indifferent simply left and said nothing, which is the quiet mechanism that inflates every small venue in this postcode.

The concession

Whatever the explanation, ninety-four is a real number, and we are not going to pretend otherwise after eighty articles of insisting that numbers matter.

Ten to fifty pounds. Cocktails. A lounge. And a perfect record across a sample that we cannot dismiss on the grounds we have been dismissing everything else.

What ninety-four unbroken fives actually costs

Think about what has to have happened.

Ninety-four separate evenings, or fragments of evenings. Ninety-four people, each with their own night, their own mood, their own reason for being out, their own tolerance for waiting.

Somewhere in that ninety-four there was a person who had just had bad news. Somewhere there was a person who had been stood up. Somewhere there was a first date that was not going well, and a birthday that nobody had organised properly, and a work drinks that somebody had been dreading for a fortnight.

And every one of them came out and gave it five stars.

Either the room is extraordinary or the sample is not what it appears, and after ninety articles the Prat has learned to bet on the second and has never once wanted to be wrong more.

Verdict

Either the best bar in this survey or the most elegant statistical anomaly in it, and we cannot tell you which, and the only way to find out is to go and become the ninety-fifth.

If you break the streak, write to us. We would very much like to know.

2 thoughts on “Permission Lounge Review: A Five-Star Rating That Actually Counts”

  1. Someone thinking about moving somewhere with competent governance. You won’t because it’s identical everywhere and that’s the actual horror.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *