City Arts Bar Review: One Hundred Articles in the Square Mile

City Arts Bar Review: One Hundred Articles in the Square Mile

A coffee house in a shed, a goose who would not die, a telescope disguised as a monument, and five million books

City Arts Bar has seventy-six reviews and a 4.5, charges twenty to sixty pounds, and it is the hundredth City article.

Seventy-six is not a sample and we will not use it. So we are going to say what we found.

What is under this square mile

A shed in a churchyard, in 1652, where a servant called Pasqua Rosee hung a picture of his own head on a sign and sold the first coffee in London – and within fifty years there were six hundred coffee houses, and Lloyd’s and the Stock Exchange had grown out of them, and every institution in this district was assembled by men sitting in one.

A goose called Old Tom, who kept escaping the block at Leadenhall until the men whose job it was to kill him gave up and started feeding him instead – and who lived to thirty-eight, and lay in state, and got an obituary in The Times.

A monument to the Great Fire that is secretly a telescope, built hollow by Robert Hooke with a laboratory underneath, in an attempt to prove that the earth moves round the sun – and it did not work, and there is no known portrait of the man who built it.

Five million books, burning in one night in December 1940, on the street beside St Paul’s.

The hundredth. And all of it is under the pavement.

And the rest

Newton, in his fifties, going into these pubs in disguise to hunt counterfeiters, and sending twenty-eight men to the gallows.

Thomas Cromwell moving his neighbours’ houses twenty-two feet backwards, on rollers, without asking, to make his garden bigger.

A company with an army of two hundred thousand men – twice the size of Britain’s – that conquered a subcontinent and paid a dividend during a famine.

Twenty thousand shopkeepers minting their own money because the Crown would not make small change.

A diver walking a thousand feet through black water, alone, to close a door.

And a footman selling the Queen’s used candle stubs, and founding Fortnum and Mason with the proceeds.

What the numbers said

The same thing they said in every other postcode.

The star rating does not measure the venue. It measures the gap between what somebody expected when they pushed the door and what they got – and the biggest inputs are the pavement outside, the price on the door, and how many people have already been through it.

Nine matched pairs proved it. Three All Bar Ones. Three Simmons. Two Cocktail Clubs. Two Bella Italias. Two bars in one building at 5.0 and 3.8.

And the formula for a good bar has not changed once in five hundred and eight articles.

A small room. A short list. Somebody behind the bar who has tasted everything on it.

Verdict

Seventy-six reviews. We cannot tell you anything, and we would be lying if we tried.

What we did not find

Orwell’s pub.

We wrote about it at the New Moon – the Moon Under Water, described in 1946 in nine hundred loving words, with ten specific qualities, and a garden with a swing in it.

And in the last paragraph he admits that there is no such pub. He knew of places with eight of the ten. Never all ten.

Five hundred and eight articles. Four postcodes. Three hundred and fifty venues.

We have not found it either.

Verdict

Seventy-six reviews. We cannot tell you anything, and we would be lying if we tried.

Go. Ask what to drink. Drink that.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *