Attributed to Robespierre, to Lenin, to Stalin – and it is one of the most dangerous sentences in politics
Broken Eggs holds a 4.8 from six hundred and nine people, charges twenty to thirty pounds, and the phrase in the name is one of the most dangerous sentences ever constructed.
You cannot make an omelette without breaking eggs
And it is attributed to everybody.
To Robespierre. To Napoleon. To Lenin. To Stalin. To a French politician nobody has heard of.
And the Prat has looked, as always, and the honest answer is that the earliest secure attributions are to nobody in particular – it appears as a French proverb, and it was already in circulation before most of the people it is credited to were born.
The famous names were attached afterwards.
What it is for
Which is the article, and it is worth being direct.
The sentence exists to excuse a cost.
It says: the thing I am doing has victims, and the victims are regrettable, and the outcome justifies them.
And it says it in the language of cookery – which is the trick, and it is a very old and very effective one.
Because an egg is a small thing, and breaking one is trivial, and the metaphor makes the cost sound minor and technical.
It is doing the work of a euphemism.
And there is a reply
Which is very good and which is also of uncertain origin.
Somebody, asked about the eggs, is supposed to have observed: I see the broken eggs, but where is this omelette of yours?
It is usually credited to Panait Istrati, a Romanian writer, on the subject of the Soviet Union.
And it is the correct question, and it is the only one that matters.
The cost is always paid in advance. The omelette is always promised for later.
Which is the finding
Eight postcodes and a thousand and one hundred and nine articles.
A thing exists. Nobody wrote down why. And a confident attribution is supplied, later, by somebody who could not bear the gap.
Hearst never said you furnish the pictures. Newton very probably never said the thing about the madness of people. The Kaiser probably never made the joke about the Merry Wives of Saxe-Coburg-Gotha.
A quotation which everybody uses and nobody can source is the most common object in the English language.
Verdict
Excellent, superb number.
Go, and ask where the omelette is.
And the egg
Which deserves a moment on its own, because it is an extraordinary object.
An eggshell is calcium carbonate – the same substance as chalk, and as limestone – and it is a millimetre thick, and it is brittle.
And it is very nearly impossible to crush by squeezing it end to end in your hand.
Because the shape is a dome, and a dome distributes a load in compression across the whole structure – which is precisely the same principle as the arch, and it is why cathedrals stand up.
It is strong exactly where it needs to be, and weak from the inside, where a chick has to get out.
The constraint made the product.
Lowri Griffiths brings a distinct voice to satirical journalism, combining cultural critique with dry humour. Influenced by London’s creative networks, her writing reflects both wit and discipline.
Her authority stems from experience, while trust is built through transparency and ethical satire.
