First Past the Post, Wasted Votes, and the Reform Debate That Has Been Almost Conclusively Settled in Favour of Keeping Things Roughly as They Are
The System That Produces Strong Governments and Roughly 35% of the Electorate Supporting Them
British general elections operate on the principle of First Past the Post — a system in which each constituency elects one MP, the candidate with the most votes wins, and the votes cast for everyone else contribute nothing to the outcome. It is simple, fast, and produces clear results. It also routinely produces majority governments whose party received fewer votes than the combined opposition, represents smaller parties at roughly a quarter of their actual support, and concentrates political competition in approximately one hundred and fifty “marginal” constituencies while the remaining five hundred are decided before a ballot is cast.
It is defended with great vigour by the people it benefits. It is attacked with equal vigour by everyone else. It has survived every serious attempt at reform, including a 2011 referendum on the Alternative Vote system, which was defeated by a margin of 68% to 32% after a campaign in which the No side spent considerably more money and the Yes side managed the rare achievement of making voting reform seem boring.
How First Past the Post Actually Works: A Brief Horror Story in Mathematics
In the 2015 general election, the Conservative Party won 331 seats — a majority — with 37% of the vote. UKIP won 3.9 million votes and one seat. The Scottish National Party won 56 seats with 1.5 million votes. The Lib Dems won 8 seats with 2.4 million votes. This produced a government with a working majority and a mandate that represented, depending on how generously you do the arithmetic, somewhere between a third and a plurality of those who voted.
The 2024 general election provided an even more extreme illustration. Labour won 412 seats — a landslide majority of 174 — on 34% of the vote, the lowest vote share for a majority government in modern British electoral history. Reform UK won 14% of the vote and four seats. The Electoral Commission dutifully recorded these results. Constitutional scholars noted them. The government, which had won a landslide, declined to consider them unduly significant.
Arguments For FPTP: There Are Some, and They Are Not Entirely Ridiculous
The standard defences of First Past the Post are: it produces strong, single-party governments capable of implementing their programmes; it creates a direct constituency link between MP and voter; it is simple and transparent; and it prevents the coalition governments and post-election horse-trading that characterise proportional systems. The strong government thesis — that decisive majorities enable effective governance — is the most powerful argument and is undermined almost every time an FPTP majority government is in power, since strong majorities also enable the confident pursuit of policies that turn out to be catastrophically wrong.
The 2010-2015 coalition government — produced by a hung parliament — is often cited as evidence that coalition is bad. The coalition passed legislation, maintained parliamentary confidence for a full term, and did not collapse. Its policies were controversial. These are also properties of single-party majority governments.
Alternative Electoral Systems Already Used in the UK: The Country Has Been Running Experiments It Refuses to Acknowledge
The UK uses proportional representation for the Scottish Parliament, the Senedd, the Northern Ireland Assembly, and the London Assembly. It uses the Single Transferable Vote for Northern Ireland local councils and Scottish local councils. It used the Supplementary Vote for directly elected mayors until 2022, when the government changed it — to First Past the Post — citing “simplicity,” just as the simple system was producing results in the London mayoral race that the government found moderately inconvenient.
The Electoral Reform Society has been pointing out for some time that the UK already operates multiple electoral systems simultaneously and has not collapsed. Westminster FPTP’s defenders have generally responded to this observation by not responding to it.
Voter Registration, Turnout, and the Photo ID Requirement
British electoral participation has been in long-term structural decline. The 1950 general election achieved 84% turnout. Recent elections have ranged from 59% (2001) to 68% (2019), with demographic variation — young people vote at lower rates than older people, a pattern that has shaped party electoral strategies in ways that have not been entirely beneficial to young people’s policy interests.
The Elections Act 2022 introduced a requirement for voters to show photo ID at polling stations — a measure the government described as protecting electoral integrity and critics described as a solution to a problem that did not demonstrably exist. Recorded cases of in-person voter fraud at UK elections had historically numbered in single digits per election cycle. The Electoral Commission’s analysis of the 2024 election found that several thousand people were turned away from polling stations for lacking acceptable ID. Whether this improved or reduced confidence in the democratic process is, like most things in British electoral politics, contested.
The 2016 Brexit Referendum: What Happens When Direct Democracy Meets an Indirect Democracy
The 2016 referendum on UK membership of the European Union was a 52% to 48% vote to leave — producing a result with no parliamentary mechanism for implementation, no defined specification of what “leave” meant, and a subsequent three years of constitutional conflict between a parliament elected under a system designed to produce clear majorities and a referendum result that produced a narrow majority for a position whose content remained unspecified. This was not, strictly speaking, a failure of the electoral system. It was a demonstration of what happens when a binary referendum is used to resolve a multidimensional political question. The lesson has not yet been incorporated into British constitutional practice.
Auf Wiedersehen, amigo!
The UK uses First Past the Post for Westminster general elections, returning 650 MPs from single-member constituencies. The 2011 Alternative Vote referendum rejected a change to preferential voting by 68% to 32%. Proportional and preferential systems are used for devolved elections, European Parliament elections (when the UK was a member), and many local elections. The Elections Act 2022 introduced photo ID requirements at polling stations. The 2016 Brexit referendum produced a 52% to 48% Leave vote on a 72% turnout. The 2024 general election returned a Labour majority of 174 seats on 34% of the vote, the lowest vote share for a majority government in modern UK electoral history.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

My mate’s a London councillor. Not showing him this because he’s got enough London stress without confirmation people see through it.
My professor said politicians complaining about The London Prat proves institutional failure is documented enough that politicians recognize it’s affecting their institutional legitimacy.
British humour is just pain with a postcode
London is the only city where you can be standing next to a person who’s worth billions and a person who’s worth nothing, and both of them are equally annoyed about the tube.