Pulse Bar Review: 4.9 From 809 People, and We Have Checked

Pulse Bar Review: 4.9 From 809 People, and We Have Checked

The highest genuine rating in the City of London, on a sample large enough that we cannot explain it away

Pulse Bar holds a 4.9 from eight hundred and nine people, and charges ten to twenty pounds.

We have to stop and look at this, because in four hundred and twenty articles across four postcodes we have seen a number like it perhaps three times.

The rule

Ratings decay with volume. It has been the iron law of this survey since the first article and it has never once failed.

Any venue that survives long enough to be reviewed by eight hundred people will have had a bad Saturday. It will have been short-staffed. It will have run out of something. And it will have served a substantial number of customers who were determined to be unhappy before they walked in.

The Harp on Chandos Place – the first London pub ever named the best in Britain – sits on a 4.6 from three and a half thousand.

Pulse is three-tenths higher, on eight hundred people, at ten to twenty pounds a head.

Pulse. Eight hundred and nine people. Almost none of them unhappy.

The only comparison

Stables Bar in Notting Hill: 4.9 from eight hundred and fifty-one. We wrote about it, we ran the arithmetic, and we admitted at the end that we could not fully explain it.

The two are almost identical in shape: a very high score, on a sample of eight hundred-odd, at a price that is not exclusive.

And that combination is the one our theory struggles with, because our theory says that a cheap venue is punished – that it draws from the whole public rather than a filtered slice, and that the whole public includes everybody having a bad day.

We defended that at the Wetherspoon, and at the Central Bar, and at the Queens Tavern, and we still believe it.

And here is a ten-to-twenty-pound bar on a 4.9.

What we think is happening

Honestly – and this is a theory and not a finding – we think it is the City.

A City bar has four good hours a day and two dead days a week. Everybody arrives at six and leaves at nine. Which means the crowd is astonishingly uniform: the same people, from the same offices, doing the same thing, at the same time, every single day.

And a uniform crowd produces a uniform score. We found exactly this with the two Be At Ones in Covent Garden, which matched exactly at 4.6 and broke our pattern – and we concluded that when the crowd is genuinely the same, the number is genuinely the same.

The City is the most homogeneous drinking population in London. It may simply be the easiest room in Britain to please, because everybody in it wants the same thing and knows they are getting it.

Verdict

Excellent, cheap, and rated higher than the best pub in Britain.

Go early. Go on a Thursday. By ten it will be empty, and that is the City, and nothing has ever changed it.

The formula, unchanged

And we should say what it is, because a 4.9 does not happen by accident and the answer is always the same.

Small room. Short list. Somebody behind the bar who has tasted everything on it and would like to tell you about it.

That is it. Four hundred and twenty articles, four postcodes, three hundred and thirty venues, and every single high-rated bar with a real sample has been that and nothing else.

Not one was themed. Not one had a rope. Not one had a hidden door, a Prohibition premise, a Victorian explorer or a colour-changing cocktail.

The industry keeps installing ropes, because a rope can be fitted in an afternoon and a person who genuinely knows the list cannot.

One thought on “Pulse Bar Review: 4.9 From 809 People, and We Have Checked”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *