The Elgin Review: Named After a Street, Named After a Man Who Took Things

The Elgin Review: Named After a Street, Named After a Man Who Took Things

Elgin Crescent is named for the Earl who removed the Parthenon marbles. The pub has a 4.4 and a very fine Victorian interior.

The Elgin on Ladbroke Grove takes its name from Elgin Crescent, which takes its name from Thomas Bruce, seventh Earl of Elgin, who is famous for exactly one thing.

Between 1801 and 1812 he removed approximately half of the surviving sculptures from the Parthenon in Athens and shipped them to Britain, where they have been ever since.

There is now a pub named, at two removes, after him. It has a 4.4 from two thousand two hundred people and a genuinely lovely Victorian interior.

The argument, stated fairly

We are a satirical magazine and we are not going to settle this, but it is worth laying out because most people have only heard one half.

Elgin’s defenders say: the Parthenon was a ruin being used as a quarry, the Ottoman authorities gave him a permit, the sculptures were being burned for lime, and had he not taken them they would not exist.

Elgin’s critics say: the permit is disputed and possibly forged, the Ottomans were an occupying power with no standing to grant it, Greece has been asking for them since 1832, and “we saved them” is what every acquisitive empire has said about everything it has ever taken.

Byron – who was there – called it plunder, in print, at the time, and never softened.

The Elgin. Named for a street, named for a man, named on a marble.

What it cost him

This is the part nobody knows and it is the most instructive.

Elgin was ruined by it. The removal and shipping consumed his personal fortune – the ship carrying part of the collection sank off Kythera and had to be salvaged over two years – and he was forced to sell the marbles to the British government in 1816 for thirty-five thousand pounds, which was substantially less than he had spent.

His marriage collapsed. His health collapsed. He lost his nose to an illness contracted in the East. He died in France in 1841, in debt, and is buried there.

He took the most famous sculptures in the world and it destroyed him, and the objects are in Bloomsbury, and the argument is not over.

The pub

Which is, mercifully, about beer.

It is a fine Victorian corner pub with a good interior, well-kept beer, a 4.4 across a real sample, and twenty to thirty pounds a head. It has a garden. It is well run and it is entirely blameless.

Nobody in it is thinking about the Parthenon. Two thousand people have reviewed it and not one has mentioned Athens.

Verdict

Good pub, superb Victorian room, and a name that arrives – via a street, via an earl – at one of the longest-running arguments in the world.

Go, have a pint, and go and look at the marbles afterwards. They are free, they are twenty minutes away, and you should form your own view.

Notting Hill, and the Crescent

One more thing, because it explains the street.

Elgin Crescent is part of the Ladbroke Estate – the great mid-Victorian development that laid out this entire district in crescents around communal garden squares, and which is the reason Notting Hill looks the way it does.

The gardens are private. They are behind the houses, locked, accessible only to the residents of the surrounding terraces, and they are the single most valuable amenity in W11.

So the street named after a man who removed a nation’s sculptures and put them behind a wall in Bloomsbury is itself built around a garden that is behind a wall, and which you cannot enter, and the Prat is not going to labour the point but it is right there.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *