J Sheekey Review: Oysters, Actors, and Absolute Discretion

J Sheekey Review: Oysters, Actors, and Absolute Discretion

St Martin’s Court’s seafood institution has been feeding the West End since 1896 and telling nobody anything

J Sheekey has been on St Martin’s Court since 1896. It sells fish. It has sold fish, continuously, through two world wars and every food trend that has swept through this city and out the other side.

It holds a 4.5 from two and a half thousand people, prices north of a hundred pounds a head, and a reputation as the place the West End actually eats – which is to say, the place where the person at the next table was on stage forty minutes ago and would very much like you not to mention it.

The discretion

This is the product. Not the fish – the fish is superb, but London has other superb fish. The product is that nobody will bother you.

J Sheekey has spent a hundred and thirty years perfecting the art of not noticing who walked in, and the entire theatre profession has responded by treating it as a canteen. The banquettes face wood panelling rather than other diners. The lighting is low without being romantic. The staff have seen everyone and will tell you nothing.

The Prat sent a correspondent to identify a famous person. He returned having identified nobody, having eaten some extremely good potted shrimp, and having been made to feel – gently, without a word being said – that the question was beneath him. That is the highest level of the craft.

J Sheekey. Everybody is in there. Nobody will confirm it.

The oyster bar

There is a separate one, and it is the correct way in for anybody not on a hundred-pound budget. Sit at the counter, have half a dozen and a glass of something white, and you are in the room for a fraction of the price with a better view of the kitchen.

This is the great open secret of expensive London restaurants and almost nobody uses it. The bar counter at a serious restaurant is the best-value seat in the building and it is nearly always empty at six o’clock.

St Martin’s Court

One of the last unruined pedestrian passages in the West End – flagstones, bollards, the stage door of the Wyndham’s at one end, and a bookshop that has been there longer than most of the theatres.

At 7:20 it is empty. At 10:05 it is full of people who have just been applauding, and it stays full until midnight, and J Sheekey does its second service to a room that is still slightly elevated from having watched something.

The fish pie

Famous, enormous, and more expensive than a fish pie should be. It is also the single most reliable dish in central London, unchanged for decades, and if you order anything else on your first visit you have made an error that the staff will be too polite to correct.

Verdict

Book. Sit at the oyster bar if the bill matters, in the room if it does not. Order the pie.

Do not look around. Everybody is looking around and nobody is finding anyone, because the building has been designed, for a hundred and thirty years, to prevent exactly that.

Official site: j-sheekey.co.uk

One thought on “J Sheekey Review: Oysters, Actors, and Absolute Discretion”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *