Reverend J W Simpson Review: A Cocktail Bar in a Former Brothel

Reverend J W Simpson Review: A Cocktail Bar in a Former Brothel

A 4.4 basement bar named after a clergyman, in premises whose past was distinctly less reverent than the name suggests

The Reverend J W Simpson is a basement cocktail bar in Fitzrovia, holds a 4.4 from three hundred and eighty-one people, and is named after a clergyman – which is a bold choice for premises whose history is, by the bar’s own telling, considerably less holy than a reverend’s name implies.

The former brothel

The bar trades on the building’s past as a former brothel, and the name is the joke made flesh: a bar named after a Reverend, in a building once dedicated to sin. The contrast is the entire concept – the pious name over the impious premises, the man of God presiding over a room that once did anything but God’s work.

The Prat’s history desk notes that Fitzrovia and neighbouring Soho have long been London’s quarter of licensed and unlicensed vice, and that a great many current bars, restaurants, and shops occupy premises with pasts that their owners now find charming precisely because they are safely over. A former brothel is, like a former smuggler’s inn, a piece of criminal history sanded smooth by time into a marketable theme.

Reverend J W Simpson. A holy name, an unholy past.

The reverend as branding

Naming a bar after a clergyman is a specific and clever piece of comic branding. A reverend represents respectability, sobriety, moral authority – the exact opposite of a cocktail bar in a former brothel. The clash is funny, and the incongruity is the point: it is the same instinct as calling a den of iniquity after a saint, or serving cocktails from a teapot.

Whether there was ever a real Reverend J W Simpson, or whether he is another invented proprietor in the tradition of Larry’s and Hudson’s House, the survey cannot say – and it barely matters. The name works whether he existed or not, because what it is really selling is the delicious contradiction between the reverend on the sign and the brothel in the bricks.

The basement, one more time

It is, inevitably, a basement bar – the underground room, the descent from the street, the speakeasy mystique that we have traced through every district. And here the basement has a genuine narrative justification for once: the below-street-level room really does suit a venue trading on a hidden, illicit past. Down the stairs, out of sight, doing something the respectable world above does not quite approve of – which is exactly what the building was built to hide.

The bar

A 4.4 across three hundred and eighty-one people is a solid, real-sample score. The reviews describe good cocktails, a characterful room, and the pleasant frisson of drinking somewhere with a genuinely disreputable past. It is doing the thing well: the drinks are serious, and the theme is worn lightly.

Verdict

A good basement cocktail bar wearing a clergyman’s respectable name over a genuinely disreputable past, trading on the delicious gap between the reverend on the door and the brothel in the bricks.

Go, descend the stairs, order something, and enjoy drinking under the name of a man of God in a room that once answered to nobody’s better nature at all.

2 thoughts on “Reverend J W Simpson Review: A Cocktail Bar in a Former Brothel”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *