Palomino Review: The Colour Cannot Be Bred True

Palomino Review: The Colour Cannot Be Bred True

Two palominos do not reliably make a palomino, because the gene that produces it does not behave

The Palomino has no rating and no reviews.

And the horse in the name is a genetic accident that cannot be reliably reproduced.

The colour

A palomino is golden, with a white or cream mane and tail.

And it is not a breed. It is a colour – and it can appear in a great many different breeds, and it is produced by a single gene doing something specific.

A chestnut horse, carrying one copy of the cream dilution gene, comes out golden.

The Palomino. Two palominos do not reliably make a palomino.

Why it cannot be bred true

Because you need exactly one copy.

Two copies of the cream gene produce a cremello – which is not golden but almost white, with blue eyes.

And no copies produce an ordinary chestnut.

Which means that breeding two palominos together gives you, on average, roughly a quarter chestnut, a quarter cremello, and only half palomino.

You cannot fix it. The colour depends on a heterozygous state, and heterozygosity does not breed true, and it never will.

The Prat’s genetic desk regards this as one of the cleanest examples in domestic animals of a highly desirable trait that is permanently unstable – and notes that breeders have been trying to get round it for a very long time and cannot.

Which is Mendel

And it is worth a line, because he is the most under-celebrated scientist in this survey.

A monk, in a garden, in Moravia, counting peas.

He worked out the fundamental rules of inheritance – dominant and recessive traits, the ratios, the whole thing – by growing something like thirty thousand pea plants and recording the results with extraordinary care.

He published in 1866.

And it was ignored, essentially completely, for thirty-four years – and he died without anybody understanding what he had done.

It was rediscovered in 1900, independently, by three separate people, all of whom then found his paper and realised he had got there first.

The name

Spanish. It appears to derive from a word for a dove, or possibly from a man’s surname, and the etymology is – as ever – contested and repeated confidently by everybody.

The Spanish horses

Which is how they got to the Americas, and which changed a continent.

There were no horses in the Americas when the Spanish arrived. There had been, long before, and they had gone extinct.

And the horses the Spanish brought escaped, and bred, and spread north across the plains – and they reached the Plains nations decades before any European did.

Which means that the mounted Plains culture that the world thinks of as ancient and defining is, in fact, entirely post-Columbian.

It lasted about two hundred years from beginning to end.

And the horse arrived as an instrument of conquest and was taken, comprehensively, by the people it was meant to be used against – who became, within two generations, among the finest light cavalry in the world.

Nothing is as old as it says it is.

Verdict

No rating. Go, and be the first.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *