The inn came first. The pub is what was left when the railways took the beds away.
The Hayden Pub and Rooms holds a 4.6 from twelve hundred and seventy-three people, which is one of the highest scores for any pub of that size in this file.
And it has rooms, which is not a modern innovation. It is the original arrangement, restored.
The inn came first
The public house, as we understand it, is a stripped-down version of something older.
The inn was the primary institution: a building on a road, where a traveller could get a bed, a meal, a drink, and stabling for a horse. The drink was one service among four, and frequently not the most important.
The coaching inn was the entire infrastructure of English travel. Coaches ran to schedules. Horses were changed. The inn yard was a terminus, a post office, a labour exchange, a market and a courtroom.
And then, in about thirty years in the middle of the nineteenth century, the railways destroyed the whole thing.
What was left
The bar.
Nobody needed the beds, because you could now be in Birmingham by lunchtime. Nobody needed the stables. Nobody needed the yard.
What survived was the room where people drank, and it was reconstituted as a business in its own right, and that is the pub – and it has spent the last hundred and seventy years being, in effect, the amputated remnant of a much larger institution.
The Prat’s hospitality desk regards this as the single most under-appreciated fact about the British pub: it is not an ancient and complete thing. It is a survivor.
And now the beds are coming back
For entirely unromantic reasons, which we have set out at the Princess Royal.
A pub in an expensive postcode cannot survive on drink alone. We have made this argument at the Richmond, the Stewart Arms, the Cock and Bottle and the Scarsdale: the freehold is worth more as flats, and the only defence is to earn more per square foot than the flats would.
Eight rooms upstairs will do it. The rooms subsidise the bar. The bar stays open.
So the pub-with-rooms is not a heritage revival. It is a financial instrument, and it happens to look exactly like the thing that existed before the trains arrived, and the resemblance is entirely coincidental.
The 4.6
Which is a very strong number on a very serious sample – twelve hundred and seventy-three people is not a fluke – and which puts the Hayden alongside the Ladbroke Arms and the Sindercombe Social at the top of the Notting Hill pub table.
And all three, when you look, are doing the same thing: being properly run, by people who are present, with no gimmick attached.
Verdict
Excellent pub, excellent rooms, and a business model that is four hundred years old and has been reinvented by an estate agent.
The yard
One thing the modern version cannot restore, and it is the thing that mattered most.
A coaching inn was built around a yard – an enclosed rectangle, with the rooms on galleries running round the inside, and the coaches and horses in the middle.
And because it was an enclosed rectangle with galleries on three sides looking down into it, it was also, in the sixteenth century, a theatre. Travelling companies played inn yards. The audience stood in the middle and hung over the galleries.
The Globe is, in its bones, a coaching inn yard made permanent and round. English theatre was born in a car park for horses.
Alan Nafzger was born in Lubbock, Texas, the son Swiss immigrants. He grew up on a dairy in Windthorst, north central Texas. He earned degrees from Midwestern State University (B.A. 1985) and Texas State University (M.A. 1987). University College Dublin (Ph.D. 1991). Dr. Nafzger has entertained and educated young people in Texas colleges for 37 years. Nafzger is best known for his dark novels and experimental screenwriting. His best know scripts to date are Lenin’s Body, produced in Russia by A-Media and Sea and Sky produced in The Philippines in the Tagalog language. In 1986, Nafzger wrote the iconic feminist western novel, Gina of Quitaque. He currently lives in Holloway, North London. Contact: [email protected]

My nan met Spike Milligan in a chemist in Lewisham. Said he was buying corn plasters and complaining about the Queen. Peak Britain.
This is what happens when someone decides to chronicle the moment when governance became exclusively about process rather than purpose or outcomes.