Elephants Head Review: The Elephant Is a Cutler’s Badge

Elephants Head Review: The Elephant Is a Cutler’s Badge

Not a Spanish princess, not the Infanta de Castile – a badge belonging to the Worshipful Company of Cutlers

The Elephants Head on Camden High Street holds a 4.3 from four thousand and sixty-one people, charges ten to twenty pounds, and the animal on the sign is a livery badge.

Not the Infanta

The story everybody tells is that Elephant and Castle is a corruption of Infanta de Castile – a Spanish princess, garbled by English mouths.

It is not.

It appears in no source before the nineteenth century, it does not survive any serious examination, and it is a folk etymology of exactly the kind we have taken apart in six postcodes.

The elephant with a castle on its back is the crest of the Worshipful Company of Cutlers.

The Elephants Head. It is a cutler’s badge. Not a princess.

Why cutlers have an elephant

Because of ivory.

Knife handles were made of it. The Cutlers’ Company – the guild of the men who made knives and blades – used ivory in enormous quantities, and the elephant is on their arms because the elephant is where the handles came from.

It is a supply chain, rendered in heraldry.

And the castle on its back is the howdah – the carrying platform strapped to a war elephant, which European heralds had heard about and had never seen, and which they drew as a small stone tower because they did not know what else to do with it.

So the sign is: a European guess at an Indian war elephant, carrying a castle it never carried, advertising the source of the material used to make knife handles.

And England has spent two centuries believing it is a Spanish princess.

The finding

Six hundred and forty-seven articles.

The tellable version wins.

The Churchill Arms was named forty-eight years before Winston was born. Old Speckled Hen is a car. Nickel is a goblin. St George was Turkish. Wolves do not howl at the moon. Absinthe never made anybody mad. The bistro is not Cossack. The margherita is not a queen.

A thing exists. Nobody wrote down why. And a beautiful explanation is supplied, later, by somebody who could not bear the gap – and it wins, permanently, because it is better than a shrug.

The pub

Cheap, busy, honest, and a 4.3 across an enormous sample – which for a large room on Camden High Street that lets everybody in is entirely correct.

Verdict

Good pub. Go, and look at the sign, and know that it is about ivory.

The howdah

Which is the small castle, and which is real.

A howdah is a platform strapped to an elephant’s back, and war elephants genuinely carried them – with archers in them, and sometimes with a small fortified structure.

They were used by Indian armies for centuries, and they were terrifying, and they were also militarily unreliable, because an elephant that panics is a catastrophe for the side that brought it.

European heralds heard about all this at several removes and drew what they imagined.

Which is why the elephants on English pub signs have masonry on their backs, with crenellations and arrow slits, which no elephant has ever carried anywhere.

One thought on “Elephants Head Review: The Elephant Is a Cutler’s Badge”

  1. The precision here about London is almost hostile. Every observation about this city earned, every detail about neighborhoods researched, every footnote about planning justified.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *