The Aztecs used cacao beans as currency, and somebody worked out how to counterfeit them
Cococure Haus holds a 4.4 from six hundred and ninety-seven reviews, charges ten to twenty pounds, and the substance in the name was, for most of its history, a bitter drink – and it was also money.
It was not sweet
Which is the first correction.
Because Mesoamerican chocolate was a drink – and it was frequently taken with chilli, and with maize, and with flowers – and it was bitter, and it was frothed by pouring it from a height between two vessels.
Sugar was a European addition. And it changed everything.
And the beans were currency
Which is genuinely true, and it is one of the best facts in economics.
Because cacao beans were used as money in the Aztec world – and there are recorded prices.
A turkey. A rabbit. A canoe. All priced in beans.
Which makes it very nearly a perfect currency
And it is worth laying out why, because it is not obvious.
It is portable. It is countable – each bean is a unit, and you cannot subdivide it, which means no fractions and no disputes.
It is durable enough. And it is scarce, because cacao grows only in particular conditions and it does not grow on the Mexican plateau.
And – crucially – it has intrinsic value. If the economy collapses you can drink your money.
And somebody counterfeited it
Which is the part that finishes the article.
Because people made fake beans.
They took the shell of a real cacao bean, emptied it, and packed it with earth or wax or avocado stone – and passed it off as the real thing.
Which is debasement. It is exactly what a mint does when it puts less silver in the coin.
Eight postcodes and thirteen hundred and four articles.
Wherever the buyer cannot check the product, somebody has to – and if nobody does, the market fills with poison.
Bread was whitened with alum. Milk was watered and chalked. Tea was hedge clippings and lead. And a cacao bean, which was money, was stuffed with mud.
And the pods are strange
Because cacao grows straight out of the trunk, and off the main branches – not on twigs, the way fruit normally does.
It is called cauliflory, and it is because the flowers are pollinated by tiny midges that live in the leaf litter on the forest floor.
The tree puts its flowers where the insects are.
Which is why cacao is extremely difficult to pollinate at scale – and why the yields are low, and why it depends utterly on a fly nobody has ever heard of.
And the bitterness is a defence
Which is the last thing, and it is the same argument as the holly.
Because theobromine – the alkaloid in cacao – is there for the same reason caffeine is in coffee, and nicotine is in tobacco.
It is a pesticide.
It is bitter and it is toxic, and it is there to stop the plant being eaten by insects – and it is precisely the compound we have spent five hundred years learning to extract, refine, sweeten and sell.
And it is why chocolate is lethal to dogs, who cannot metabolise it.
The constraint made the product – and we are all eating the poison a tree made to protect itself.
Verdict
Good, cheap, honest number.
Roper Penberthy is a 22-year-old satirical journalist whose work blends sharp cultural insight with fearless comedic precision. Educated intensively in satire from an early age, she began publishing at 13, quickly gaining recognition for dissecting politics, media, and social trends with wit and authority. Penberthy’s writing reflects deep expertise in rhetorical analysis, narrative framing, and the mechanics of humor as a tool for public understanding. Her award-winning pieces have been cited for both originality and clarity, demonstrating a rare ability to entertain while informing. Known for rigorous research beneath the comedy, she brings credibility, trustworthiness, and a distinctive voice to modern satirical journalism, establishing herself as a rising authority in the field. EMAIL [email protected]

This reads like someone’s been to planning meetings they shouldn’t have been at, taking obsessive notes and processing trauma into literature.