Smugglers Tavern Review: There Was Nothing to Smuggle Here

Smugglers Tavern Review: There Was Nothing to Smuggle Here

Bloomsbury is about as far from the sea as central London gets, which makes it a bold choice for a smuggling theme

Smugglers Tavern holds a 4.3 from eight hundred and twenty-one people, and sits in Fitzrovia, which is roughly as far from the sea as it is possible to be in central London.

The geography problem

Smuggling requires a coast. It requires coves, beaches, tides, and boats coming in at night with contraband to be hidden before the excise men arrive. It is a fundamentally maritime crime, romantic precisely because of the cliffs and the moonlight and the barrels rolled up from the shore.

Fitzrovia has none of these things. It is landlocked, urban, and about as nautical as a filing cabinet. The nearest tide is a long walk south, past the whole of the West End, to a river that was itself walled off from smuggling by the docks and the customs house centuries ago.

The Prat’s geography desk has established that if anybody had tried to smuggle anything into Fitzrovia by sea, they would have run aground somewhere around Trafalgar Square and been arrested for confusion.

Smugglers Tavern. In Fitzrovia. Landlocked. Bold.

The romance of crime

So why the name? Because smuggling, like piracy, has been thoroughly laundered by time into something charming.

Actual smuggling was violent, ruthless organised crime that funded itself through tax evasion and settled disputes with murder. The smuggling gangs of the eighteenth century were feared and brutal. But two hundred years of distance have turned them into loveable rogues in tricorn hats, and a pub can now use the word “smugglers” the way it might use “pirates” – as a wink, a bit of fun, a suggestion of harmless roguery.

We saw the identical process in the last survey with the Bootlegger and every Prohibition-themed basement in Covent Garden: real criminal enterprise, sanded down by nostalgia into a decorative theme you can charge a premium for.

The honest defence

To be fair to the place, a pub name does not have to be geographically accurate to be a good name. Smugglers Tavern is evocative, it is memorable, and it promises a certain dark, low-beamed, contraband-rum atmosphere that is genuinely appealing on a wet Tuesday.

And a 4.3 from eight hundred people is a solid, real-sample score. Whatever the geographic absurdity, the pub is doing its job, and the customers are not filing complaints about the distance to the nearest cove.

Verdict

A good, atmospheric, entirely landlocked pub trading on the romance of a maritime crime that could not possibly have happened within two miles of it.

What Bloomsbury actually smuggled

If the district smuggled anything, it was ideas. This is the neighbourhood of radical presses, banned books, and dangerous thinking – Marx across the road at the Museum, the Bloomsbury Group scandalising the establishment, the university a constant engine of arguments the authorities would rather not hear.

The real contraband of Bloomsbury was intellectual, not physical. Nobody rolled barrels of brandy up from a cove. But a great many people carried dangerous thoughts through these streets, which is a kind of smuggling the pub sign could not possibly depict, and which is far more in keeping with the district than any tricorn hat.

Verdict

A good, atmospheric, entirely landlocked pub trading on the romance of a maritime crime that could not possibly have happened within two miles of it.

Go, order a dark rum, and enjoy the smuggling theme in the one part of London where absolutely nothing has ever been smuggled ashore.

2 thoughts on “Smugglers Tavern Review: There Was Nothing to Smuggle Here”

  1. My professor said politicians complaining about The London Prat proves institutional dysfunction is real enough that politicians can’t ignore it anymore.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *