Sportsman Review: A 4.1, and Half the Room Loses Every Single Time

Sportsman Review: A 4.1, and Half the Room Loses Every Single Time

Sixteen hundred people, and the sports bar is being marked down for the result of a football match

The Sportsman holds a 4.1 from sixteen hundred and fifty-one people, charges ten to twenty pounds, and it is a sports bar.

And we are going to defend the number, because it is structural.

The sports penalty

Which is simple, and brutal, and entirely unavoidable.

Half the room is unhappy by definition. Every single time.

Because a football match has a loser – and the people who came to watch their team lose are, at the final whistle, having a bad evening.

The Sportsman. Half the room loses. And some of them blame the room.

And they blame the room

Not consciously. Not deliberately.

But a person who has just watched something painful, in a crowded bar, and who writes a review of that bar within twenty-four hours, is not writing about the beer.

They are writing about how they felt in that building – and how they felt was bad, and the building was there when it happened.

The stack

And this venue is carrying several penalties at once.

Cheap is punished. A cheap venue draws from the whole public rather than a filtered slice – which means it gets everybody, including everybody having a bad night.

Volume is punished. Sixteen hundred reviews is sixteen hundred chances to have had a bad evening, and every one is in the average forever.

Crowds are punished. A packed room means somebody was jostled, and somebody could not get to the bar, and somebody could not see the screen.

And Stratford is punished, because it is a footfall district – and a great many of these customers did not choose this bar, they chose the nearest one to the stadium.

They are not rating the bar. They are rating their feet.

Which is the whole survey

Eight postcodes and twelve hundred and ninety-one articles.

The star rating does not measure the venue.

It measures the gap between what somebody expected when they pushed the door and what they got – and it is contaminated, every time, by the price, the hour, the pavement, the weather, and the result of the match.

And the screen is the product

Which the trade will not admit.

Because a sports bar is not selling drink. It is selling a subscription you cannot afford.

The broadcast rights cost the operator a very substantial sum every year – and the entire proposition is: we have paid for the thing you cannot watch at home.

Which means the costs are enormous, the margins are thin, and it is being reviewed by people who are furious about a penalty decision.

What we would tell them

Almost nothing. There is very little to fix.

They cannot stop the football having a loser.

What they can do is ask for the review – politely, once, on the way out, of the people who are smiling.

Because an unprompted sample is systematically biased towards the furious – and in a sports bar, half the room is furious about something the venue did not do and could not have prevented.

It is free, it is legal, and it takes four seconds.

Verdict

Cheap, and a better number than the score suggests.

Verdict

Cheap, and a better number than the score suggests.

One thought on “Sportsman Review: A 4.1, and Half the Room Loses Every Single Time”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *