Shoreditch Arms Review: Nobody Has Any Arms

Shoreditch Arms Review: Nobody Has Any Arms

An arms pub is flying a coat of arms, and a district cannot have one, and nobody has ever asked

The Shoreditch Arms on Kingsland Road holds a 4.4 from two thousand one hundred and twenty people, charges ten to thirty pounds, and it is flying a coat of arms that does not exist.

What an arms pub is

The Wellington Arms is flying the arms of the Duke of Wellington. The Marquess of Anglesey is flying his.

The Bricklayers Arms is flying the coat of arms of the Worshipful Company of Bricklayers, which is a real institution with a real grant of arms.

An arms pub is displaying somebody’s heraldry, and it is telling you whose land you are on, or whose patronage the house enjoys, or which guild drinks there.

That is what the word means. It is not decoration and it was never decoration.

The Shoreditch Arms. A district cannot have a coat of arms.

And a district cannot have one

Coats of arms are granted to people, to families, to corporations and to institutions.

They are not granted to neighbourhoods. Shoreditch does not have arms. There is no escutcheon hanging over that door because there is nothing to hang.

The name is a modern construction: take the district, add Arms, and you have a pub name that sounds like it has been there for two hundred years.

And it works perfectly. Nobody has ever questioned it, and two thousand one hundred and twenty people have reviewed the place without once wondering whose arms are on the sign.

The drift

Which is the story of every pub name in six postcodes.

Arms meant heraldry.

Tavern meant wine, and specifically not beer, and the distinction was legal.

Inn meant beds.

Alehouse meant ale and only ale, and a man who sold wine in one was committing an offence.

And every one of them now means, simply, pub.

Five hundred and seventy articles, five hundred and seventy venues, and the words on the front of them are the fossils of a licensing system, a class system and a heraldic system – all three of which have completely collapsed – and the words are still there, doing nothing, meaning nothing, and nobody minds.

Which is fine

And we have come round to it, and it took six postcodes.

A pub name is a handle. It exists so that one person can tell another where to meet. It does not need to be true.

The Shoreditch Arms is in Shoreditch. Both people know which building is meant. That is the entire specification and it has been met.

Verdict

Good pub. Go, and enjoy a coat of arms belonging to nobody.

Where the word came from

Shoreditch, which everybody assumes is a shore and a ditch.

It is not, and the folk explanation – involving Jane Shore, mistress of Edward IV, supposedly dying in a ditch here – is a complete invention. It is a back-formation from the name, and it appears centuries too late, and the district was already called Soersditch long before she was born.

The likeliest derivation is a personal name, or a drain – a sewer ditch, which is considerably duller and considerably more probable.

Six postcodes and five hundred and seventy articles, and it has never once varied.

The tellable version wins. And a woman is very often the one it is hung on.

One thought on “Shoreditch Arms Review: Nobody Has Any Arms”

  1. The thing about planning meetings is they’re theatre where the outcome’s predetermined and everyone’s acting out predetermined parts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *