Canalside Review: A 3.6, and Twenty-Two People Decided It

Canalside Review: A 3.6, and Twenty-Two People Decided It

Deep in the dead zone, on the canal, in the market – three separate penalties on one venue

Canalside Bar holds a 3.6 from twenty-two reviews.

Twenty-two.

And this venue is carrying three separate penalties at once, and none of them is about the drinks.

The dead zone

Between roughly twenty and sixty reviews, a venue is trapped.

It has enough that people will look at the score and believe it. And it has few enough that four bad nights cannot be outvoted.

Four one-star reviews out of twenty-two is a 3.6.

Four one-star reviews out of six hundred is a rounding error and the score does not move.

The bar may be identical. The only difference is how many people came afterwards.

Canalside. Twenty-two reviews, on the canal, in the market. Three penalties.

The market penalty

Which we named at Lock 17 and which applies with full force here.

A very large proportion of the people who walk into a bar at Camden Lock have already been in the market for three hours.

They are tired. They have been in a crowd. They are carrying bags. They have walked eleven thousand steps.

And they are not choosing a bar. They are sitting down.

What they actually want is a chair, quiet, and to be left alone – and a busy canalside bar on a Saturday cannot provide any of those, because it is full of other people who want exactly the same thing.

They are not rating the bar. They are rating their feet.

The transient penalty

Which is the third.

A local pub is reviewed by regulars, who have a relationship with the room and forgive an off night, because they will be back on Thursday.

A market bar is reviewed by people who came once – who have no baseline, and for whom that single visit, on the busiest day, at the busiest hour, is the entire dataset.

The mirror

3 Locks Brewing, ten minutes away, holds a 4.8 from five hundred and eighty-seven people.

It is up a side street. Nobody arrives there by accident. Everybody in it chose to be.

Same canal. Same district. One point two stars.

What the number is not measuring

Whether the room is any good. It has never measured that once in seven hundred and forty-seven articles.

It measures the price, the hour, the pavement, how many people have already been through the door, and the condition the customer was in when they arrived.

Nobody controls for any of it.

Verdict

Twenty-two reviews. Not a verdict.

Go on a Wednesday. It is a different bar.

The one fix

Print the review count at the same size as the score.

Not underneath. Not in grey. Not smaller. The same size, the same weight, the same line.

Do that, and a 3.6 from twenty-two people is visibly a coin toss rather than a verdict, and a 4.8 from fifteen thousand is visibly the most reliable number on the page.

It would cost nothing. It would take an afternoon.

It will never happen, because the ambiguity is worth money to somebody, and it is not worth money to you.

2 thoughts on “Canalside Review: A 3.6, and Twenty-Two People Decided It”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *