Simmons Piccadilly Review: The Last of Four, and the Case Is Closed

Simmons Piccadilly Review: The Last of Four, and the Case Is Closed

4.8, 4.7, 4.7, 4.7 – across twelve thousand people and two districts, and nobody else has come close

Simmons at Piccadilly Circus holds a 4.7 from sixteen hundred and eighty-seven people and charges ten to twenty pounds.

It is the fourth and last Simmons in this survey, and the four of them together have done something that no other chain in six hundred and twenty-four articles has managed.

The final table

Bank: 4.8 from two thousand three hundred and twenty-nine.

Monument: 4.7 from two thousand two hundred and twenty-one.

Soho: 4.7 from five thousand seven hundred and thirty.

Piccadilly Circus: 4.7 from sixteen hundred and eighty-seven.

A spread of one-tenth of a star, across four branches, in two districts, on a combined sample of nearly twelve thousand people.

Simmons. Four branches. One-tenth. Twelve thousand people.

Everybody else drifts

Five Be At Ones: 4.6, 4.6, 4.3, 4.5, 4.6 – a spread of three-tenths.

Three Cocktail Clubs: 4.7, 4.5, 4.4 – three-tenths.

Three Prince of Wales pubs: 4.6, 4.4, 4.2 – four-tenths.

Two Bootleggers: 5.0 and 4.3 – seven-tenths, and the explanation is entirely sample size.

Two bars in the same building, same operator, same night: 5.0 and 3.8.

The rating measures the gap between expectation and delivery, and the gap moves with the pavement – which is why almost every chain in this survey drifts, and why Simmons does not.

And Piccadilly Circus is the test

Because it should be the worst of them.

It is the most tourist-saturated, most exhausting, most over-trafficked square of pavement in Britain. Everybody arriving at that door has been walking for four hours, has been jostled, has been overcharged, and has already decided the day has been slightly too long.

We watched exactly this destroy the Cocktail Club at Oxford Circus, which sits three-tenths below its sister branch for no other reason.

And Simmons at Piccadilly Circus holds a 4.7, identical to the City and to Soho, on a serious sample.

How

By promising almost nothing and clearing it.

The list is long and cheap. The room is loud. There is no rope, no door policy, no hidden entrance, no premise, and nobody is going to make you feel stupid for ordering wrongly.

Archer Street is a four-minute walk away and holds a 3.3 from nine hundred and twenty people, and it is entirely about the door.

Simmons has no door. And the number is the result.

Verdict

Excellent value, genuinely good drinks, and the most consistent chain in five postcodes by a distance nobody else is near.

What consistency costs

An enormous amount, and it is completely invisible.

To hold the same number across four sites you need the same training, the same stock, the same measures, the same recipes and the same recruitment – and every one of those is a system somebody must build, maintain and audit, forever, at cost.

The independent bar with a 4.9 achieved it with one exceptional person behind the counter. That does not scale and it cannot be bought.

A chain holding a 4.7 across twelve thousand people has done something different and much harder to explain, and the trade press has never once written about it, because it is not a story.

Verdict

Excellent value, genuinely good drinks, and the most consistent chain in five postcodes by a distance nobody else is near.

Go before seven. The two-for-one is the entire point.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *