Opera Tavern Review: 4.8 From Two Thousand People

Opera Tavern Review: 4.8 From Two Thousand People

One of the highest genuine ratings in either survey, on a sample large enough that it cannot be explained away

Opera Tavern holds a 4.8 from two thousand and ninety-nine people.

We need to stop and look at that, because across three hundred and twenty-three articles and nearly three hundred venues in two surveys, we have seen a number like this perhaps four times.

Why it should not be possible

Ratings decay with volume. This is the iron law of the review economy and we have been demonstrating it since the first article.

Every venue that survives long enough to be reviewed by two thousand people will, inevitably, have had a bad Saturday. It will have been short-staffed. It will have run out of something. And it will have served a meaningful number of customers who were determined to be unhappy before they walked through the door.

The Harp on Chandos Place – the first London pub ever named the best in Britain – sits on a 4.6 from three and a half thousand.

Opera Tavern is two-tenths higher, on two thousand people.

Opera Tavern. Two thousand people. Almost all of them delighted.

What that actually requires

Something in the region of eighty-five per cent of everybody who has ever eaten there awarding full marks, and essentially nobody awarding one star.

Two thousand separate evenings. Two thousand people with their own moods, their own reasons for being out, and their own tolerance for a wait.

Somewhere in that number there was a person who had just had bad news. There was a first date going badly. There was a work dinner that somebody had been dreading for a fortnight.

And they all came out and gave it five.

The obvious explanation

It is very good. That is genuinely the most likely answer and we should say so plainly rather than reaching for statistics.

It is a Salt Yard Group room – Spanish and Italian small plates, done seriously, in a converted pub on Catherine Street, with an open kitchen and a charcoal grill.

The Iberico pork and foie gras burger has been on the menu for years and is one of the two or three most ordered dishes in Covent Garden. It is the size of a plum. It costs more than it should. Nobody has ever complained.

And the formula holds

Small room. Short menu. Somebody who knows.

Three hundred and twenty-three articles, two postcodes, and every single venue we have found at the top of the table – Stables, Amaro, Kioku, Bedford Street Wines, Ricco, Wild, Akoya – has been exactly that, and not one has been themed, and not one has a rope.

Opera Tavern is the largest sample we have ever seen it hold on.

Verdict

Thirty to eighty pounds. Book. Sit at the counter if you can, which is always the best seat and which almost nobody takes.

Order the burger. Order more than you think. This is the best-rated restaurant in either survey and it has earned every point.

What a 4.8 at n=2,099 is worth

More than any other number in either survey, and it is worth saying why.

A 5.0 from one review is an anecdote. A 4.9 from eleven is noise. A 4.9 from eight hundred and fifty – which is Stables Bar in Notting Hill – is genuinely extraordinary and we could not explain it.

But a 4.8 from two thousand and ninety-nine is something else entirely. It is unfakeable, unbuyable, and statistically almost immovable. Nothing that happens on any given night can shift it. It represents a venue that has been consistently excellent, to a genuine cross-section of the public, for years.

It is the most reliable single number we have found in three hundred and twenty-three articles, and if you take one recommendation from this entire magazine, take this one.

One thought on “Opera Tavern Review: 4.8 From Two Thousand People”

  1. London is the only city where you can be surrounded by millions of people and still feel completely, utterly alone—and somehow that’s a comfort.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *